Joined: 23 Mar 2009 United States Lessons: 1 Karma: 1
Its not really just "A" chord that makes a song sad, its the progression and the feel you portray. Fill a progression with lots of minor chords, and slow tempo and you'll have something sad.
Diminished i don't think is really sad sounding persay.
Joined: way back United Kingdom Lessons: 1 Karma: 20 Moderator
Crunch says:
I feel that D Minor is the saddest of keys, it instantly makes people weep.
Haha! Good old Nigel Tufnel!
And patleh, see if you can work it out yourself - I promise it's not that hard and the feeling you get from working something out yourself rather than somebody else telling you is far better!
Joined: 04 Jan 2007 United Kingdom Licks: 1 Karma: 11 Moderator
It's definately more about the progression than just one chord. The intro and verse of Nutshell by Alice in Chains uses Em7, D and Cadd9 chords. Only one minor chord in there, but the decent of the root notes from E to D to C coupled with the sparse instrumentation and slow tempo make it a really sad song.
Joined: way back United States Lessons: 2 Karma: 21
It doesn't matter that there is only one minor chord in the progression, the minor chord is the HOME position. Of course with a minor tonic you will always have a sad sounding song. Any progression of 654, or 645 (using a major scale, meaning 6 = relative minor) will always sound sad. That's just how music theory works.