blackholesun wrote:Yeah, if you're in first school and you can't think of a proper adjective to use.im sorry i didnt get it, what do u mean by that? if you're talking about my sentence above ya i know theres something wrong in it(that band,band sounds), i just reread it now. or are u talking about using the right adjective for describing PT. and what do u mean by "first school"? I SAID THATS MY OPINION, MAYBE THE BAND DOESN'T SUCK, BUT WHEN IT COMES TO ME IT DO SUCK >> MY OPINION!! and No it's not one great guitarist that makes the band really good.
Where are all the good guitarists nowadays?
First school, elementary school. It just seems childish to say that something sucks, as if you don't know what else you can say. Anyhow, it doesn't matter. Give them another listen though, it took me a while to get into them as well.
no I'm not in elementary school I'm 18 :S I finished highschool 3 years ago, thats not what I meant when I said its hard to explain... Anyways
Nightmare, you seem to be forgetting the point of forums. They are for discussion of opinions and what you offered wasn't really discussion... just an over exaggerated statement - so what was the point?
'Doz what's with all that negativisim!!!!??? Did i kill someone? Plz tell me what wrong have u done to u. Am I the first one who posts his opinion on this website.. my statement was related to a discussion and not to start a discussion, plus it turned out to be a discussion about opeth guitarist and PT band after u told me to give out a reason..
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=acrQGBYz_vg
heres something else that is quite unlike anything ive heard
I'll post what's on my profile:
"So much of what's good about music ceases to make sense when you attempt to analyse it from a 'Who's the best?' perspective" - Guthrie Govan
Get it?
I'm not being negative, for you to just state a band sucks is negative.
And I agree with Jazz absolutely.
'Doz you dont expect me to like all bands do u? can you plzz just close the topic.
'Jazzy ya i got it, and thats true ya, but why are you posting this? I'm not doing that, im not trying to analyse music from...
'Bodom nice, but i never heard of them. where are they from?
I'm not just posting that to you NM, I'm posting it to everyone.
Everyone seems to have this major competitive thing in them that makes them think only what they hear is the best. When they haven't even bothered to properly check other things out.
It makes them blind to all other skills around them, and they'll be nothing but narrow minded musicians.
JazzMaverick wrote:Everyone seems to have this major competitive thing in them that makes them think only what they hear is the best. When they haven't even bothered to properly check other things outNo jazzy thats not true, i always try to listen to other stuff and check out different genres or artists that interests a majority or a minority of people.
theyre from MOntreal Canada i think
I always wanted to go to Montreal :( :( :( :(
You're missing the point. I'm not saying you had to like them, or that you can't have an opinion. I'm saying that you should try to offer more to the conversation than an over exaggerated statement of your opinion - because that's what these forums are for - discussion.
'Doz I know what you meant, you made yourself clear the first time and so did I, so why are you making us repeat ourselves.. can you please end that topic now..
agreed, enough of that
There are some great guitarists out there today that will fill the shoes of the greats back in the day. Good music will always live on simply because music is a language we all understand. Here is my list of some guitarists today who have some amazing skills.
John Mayer
John Frusciante
Joe Bonamassa
Jonny Lang
John Butler
Ben Harper
Derek Trucks
Ronert Randolph
Chris Thile (usually plays Mandolin)
Jack Johnson
Keb' Mo'
Matthew Followill
Mike Einziger
Dave Matthews
Tim Reynolds
Ron Block
Dan Tyminski
Tad Kinchla
Kyle McDonald
Mat McHugh
Mason Jennings
William Evans Benoit
John J. Driscoll
Chad Urmston
Brad Corrigan
Bon Iver
Damien Rice
Ray LaMontagne
Xavier Rudd
To name a few....this list contains guitarists who play many different styles and genres, such as blues, rock, southern rock, roots, slide, ska, reggae, acoustic, folk, bluegrass, jazz, metal, alternative, eclectic, etc. Like I said, there are many outstanding guitarists out there in today's music.it just takes a little searching to find the talent that is around just like it was in earlier years.
there are some pretty good guitarists out there like synyster gates, its just his songwriting that isnt very good at all. A7X is a perfect example of some dip***s getting together and playing the same stuff over and over again. its really sad. Bands like Coheed and Cambria are really good songwriters, but there solos could use a little more work.
i think the good ones are here. and by here i mean the guitarists trying to learn as much as they can, going to lessons, practacing , and goign on forums like this.
I feel like Acoustic guitar has made a comeback, with all the electronic ** flooding the market, it's nice to hear some soulful, beautiful, UNEDITED music. Just that raw sound can do so much.
Xavier Rudd is amazing. John Mayer is okay... but his ego is not something you want to be associated with.
I mean, great guitarists just don't exist anymore. I think a lot of people feel that the extent to what you can do with a guitar has almost peaked. No one really wants to experiment with it that much. However, electronic stuff is starting to hit the market and you see alot more people playing MIDI and other forms of electronic music control. That's the next step, not the next Hendrix or SRV
I disagree Jeff, check out bands like Trivium, Luna Mortis, Nevermore, Symphony X, Children of Bodom, Opeth, Dream Theater, Lamb of God, Shadows Fall and Unearth. All those bands have released and will continue to release guitar dominating albums. The guitar players in these bands always try and push themselves to get better and crazier with their playing. Sure they don't play like SRV, Satch or Vai, but they can play the crap out of their instruments.
If you want to hear good guitar, listen to metal. That's where the a lot of todays incredible guitar players hideout. Of course you will always have good guitarists in other genres as well, but I think metal will be the strong hold for excelling guitar players. Most metal is pretty raw, of course you have bands like Dragon Force that use all kinds of crazy effects, but a lot of new metal bands are really bringing back gutiar shred as it should be, which is awesome!
yeah "good" guitarists is just another opinion thing, if you like the shred-the-crap-outta-guitar thing, then yeah theres quite alot of good guitarists. but if you like slower more mellow music theres not as much i guess
True that Bodom.
Agreed with both of you.
Music is about the individual. I personally find good music in EVERY genre. Humans are bound to changing interests, which is exactly why music is so interesting; to see where we started out, and to see the enormous quantity we've made since then. Music itself is a blessing, and it affects each person differently. We should just appreciate the fact we have something that saves us from insanity.
I agree too. I like how oyu can get guitarists who adopt different techniques and seem to have different strenghts and weaknesses in their playing, I don't think there is one who can do literally play everything no matter how good they generally are.
buckethead can play just about anything lol
@Guitarslinger124
True, metal has great guitarists, but the power chord hungry rhythm of most metal music really turns me off. I mean... when the majority (I say majority as a categorical thing. Of course there are bands that do not follow this trend) just play fast power chord changes over a double bass drum, it gets boring to me.
If you've heard any of the music I play, I'm looking for the next Eric Clapton, the next B.B. King, the next big bluesy/rock player. There are many great musicians, but none that you can say flat out are paving a new path for musicians to follow. It's just not there anymore.
I guess you can blame that on the over exposure of the internet to musicians and the way you can promote yourself... and the fact that people will listen to someone talking about a poker face...
to justjeff. check out keller williams, john butler, or tim reynolds if you want good acoustic guitarists. and check out jake cinnegar and billy bayliss from umphreys mcgee. one of the best guitar duos of today i think.
and yes buckethead can play everything. no joke.
@morphdusseldorf
Tim Reynolds is crazy good. I've seen him perform with Dave Matthews and they are a killer combination.
John Butler is by far my hero. He has such a great understanding of rhythm and composition. His technique is insane! I love his song "Ocean" and bought his CD "Grand National" last year... love the CD to death.
Never heard of Keller Williams or Umphrey McGee... I'll have to check them out. There's a lot more great acoustic music, with Ben Harper, Xavier Rudd, Donavan Frankenreiter, and many more that I can't thing of off the top of my head.
JustJeff wrote:True, metal has great guitarists, but the power chord hungry rhythm of most metal music really turns me off. I mean... when the majority (I say majority as a categorical thing. Of course there are bands that do not follow this trend) just play fast power chord changes over a double bass drum, it gets boring to meI am a fan of many different styles of music. I listen to everything from the Yellow Jackets to Behemoth or The Blue Man Group to Sergei Rachmaninov. However, metal is by far my favorite genre, the reason being (granted there are some metal bands that suck, but don't judge all for one) metal has the most diverse musicianship I have ever heard. I believe the number of talented guitarist, bassist and drummers that exist in the metal community outway that of any other genre. Also, when I say metal, I don't mean bands like Metallica, Iron Maiden, Black Sabbath, Judas Priest or Korn. Check out bands like, Symphony X, Dream Theater, Lamb of God, Shadows Fall, Children of Bodom, Divine Heresy, Megadeth, Pantera, Unearth, Opeth, Nevermore or Luna Mortis. These bands employ some of the most brilliant guitar playing and they truly stand out as premere musicians.
on a side note, if you want to hear the brilliance in Children of Bodom listen to the first 2 albums