Where are all the good guitarists nowadays?
It seems that the mainstream rock of today doesnt contain any good guitarists. Why is this?
You're worng.. i think this topic should be deleted, thats my opinion.
Why dont you just tell me your opinion on the matter. I think that in mainstream rock the guitarists dont play anything difficult. Its all just simple chords progressions and sometimes if your lucky youll get a less than climactic guitar solo.
i found one...ready?
its meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee! lol
mainstream "rock"sucks. nowadays "rock" is pop. which is ***. if a band that played songs anything like used to be made, id pay attention to them. now...its very hard to find one "mainsream" rock band i like...if i even like just one.
yup, rock sucks nowadays.. curse nickleback and our lady peace!
No its not that dumbasses, there was crap before and there's crap now, it's just that today there are more bands and artists.
Nightmare wrote:No its not that dumbasses, there was crap before and there's crap now, it's just that today there are more bands and artists.hence more crap is being produced. some one call al gore and tell him its not cars causing global warming...its the bands nowadays producing "crap"! lol.
No, more bands = more crappy ones AND more good ones.
theres loads of good guitarists you just need to look.
i dont get all this naysaying of how music is **** now, as far as im concerned a lot of it is mint.
the cribs - look at ryan jarman some of his guitar work is pretty mint as is johnny marr , ex smiths man who recently joined them
arctic monkeys - alex turner is a great guitarist as well
not my kind of thing but some of these metal bands such as trivium seem to have some pretty mint guitar tunes.
just depends what floats your boat.
blackholesun i think posted a link to a hellacopters track a while bakc, i think those guys are a great new rock band.
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YgHHFKpxjKs
John Frusciante is good:
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sUJHEdQBAr8
Johnny Greenwood is pretty good:
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m3glsQailcA
I'd say Radiohead and RHCP are pretty mainstream.
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KxPr5jnszy0Alter Bridge | Mark Tremonti
^ Oh I didn't see Joe mention the Arctic Monkeys, they're pretty cool. Also, one could make a case for Tom Morello. And there's lots of good metal guitarists around (though they're less mainstream).
Johnny is awesome, one of my favorite.
Time after time this basic thread comes up under a different title. it's rather tiring. Every one is listening to old music, classic guitarist like Randy Rhodes, Jimmy Page, Hendrix, Pete Townsend what ever else.
If you keep looking for great guitarists in yesterdays music your going to find yesterdays great guitarists. If you want today great guitarist then listen to today music. Better yet, how about tomorrows music, check out the indie, and un-signed music of myspace and else were on the internet.
Get over it already
What exactly are we defining as mainstream?
You said exactly the same people I was going to GRX :) I would include the whole band though, so Jonny, Ed O'Brien, and Thom Yorke.
Omar Rodriguez-Lopez is really good, Tom Morello, Stone Gossard and Mike McCready of Pearl Jam, James Hetfield and Kirk Hammett, Jack White, the guys in Opeth... all kinds of really good metal guitarists. So yeah, look harder.
Edit: Sweet video of Frusciante going off.
i definatly would not say opeth is mainstream...
BodomBeachTerror wrote: i definatly would not say opeth is mainstream...Opeth is definitely mainstream.
opeth is death metal lol
Opeth is black metal and it is relativly mainstream.
How about John Petrucci of Dream Theater?
I'd have to agree with Telecrater though there are a fair share of great guitarists in modern music but we as musicans and of an...educational age are to busy looking into the past, my opinion is that it is due to the music other people en-lighten us to in academic places, it makes us believe/feel 'modern music is pants, look into the old' so yes we may gain things but we gain nothing new and lose out on contempory music to learn from.
I'd also have to agree on looking at the indie/un-signed bands/musicans, hell I've found some really insperational bands and some amazing guitarists in my own area through myspace and it's like.
Mainstream is generally any established band that has gained worldwide fame or notoriety. Just because a band plays a particular genre of music doesn't exclude it from being mainstream.
I mean, if you can go into a major chain store like Best Buy and find an album by a band like Opeth (which I did about two weeks ago), then I would classify them as mainstream.
Back on topic. There are plenty of great guitarists out there. There's just so wide of a market that it's hard to narrow down what you would define as a great guitarist in such a growing and competitive profession.
it really depends on what mainstream is.. i would say its something that plays on the radio.. i have NEVER heard Opeth or Dream Theater on the radio
That's it Bodom. THE RADIO. Hip Hop, Pop, Country, Talk, and Spanish dominate the radio. At least in the L.A. area. If it were'nt for the internet and sattelite radio, it would suck for us guitar people. Almost all major radio stations in L.A. in the 70's and 80's were rock stations. And when I say rock I mean metal, punk, classic rock, everything! But know it's all crap.
Nutter166 wrote:Opeth is black metal and it is relativly mainstreamwhat! no. opeth is progressive death metal
avenged sevenfold have pretty good guitarists and id say theyre pretty mainstream. muse have an amazing guitarist and you can really get as mainstream as them lol. the legendary solo guitarists are still kicking out the good stuff. the offspring has two good guitarists, sum 41. i can go on forever, just goes to show there are plenty out there you just got to look.
I think brodyxhollow described mainstream fairly accurately: You could go into a chain store and pick up an album. Out of my selections, I would actually be more surprised to see The Mars Volta (Omar Rodriguez-Lopez) in a chain store's selection.
sum 41,muse,the offsprings.. dude shut up before they kill u
you dont really understand, just because they dont bust out 2 minute solos doesnt mean theyre not good. anyways thats your opinion if they **. i dont care, makes no difference to what i think. also matt belamy from muse is actually a much better guitarist than you think
No I don't mean that. in fact muse guitarist is really good, but it just that almost everyone here thinks that alternative and punk music are crap.
matter of opinion really infact i really like that sort of music and it just shows that almost everyone here needs to expand their horizons that little bit more, and stop being so intolerent of others music.
muse is good, but theyre pretty indy. not really punk
I didnt say muse are punk, I was talking in general. Sum41 are punk
Sum41 is **, not punk.
Nothing has really been punk since around the 70s.
no they're punk, I know what do u mean but punk has changed.. Stiff little fingers my favorite
As different genres of rock develop they sooner or later become mainstream. Once the genre hits mainstream it's no longer about the quality of the music itself but money. It then becomes more about production of the music, the image of the band, and its ability to attract large audiences. Punk is a great example of how a whole genre can be ruined by money.
A good punk band is one that no one knows of except for the small following it has in its town. The lead singer is usually a drug attict who eventually overdoses and dies, the lead guitarists ends up in jail for assault and other charges, and the drumer marries his long time girlfriend and becomes an accountant for her dads firm.
i think that yes, mainstream can ruin a genre. rock has been ruined in my opinion. in the 70's, rock was about melodies and harmonies and the songs had alot of meaning to them(this was mainstream then). Now the mainstream stuff, is about what will appeal to the younger people this generation. Rock isnt the mainstream type of music anymore though I think rap or something like that is.
Nightmare wrote:No, more bands = more crappy ones AND more good ones.tell me of some good mainstream rock bands and i will be happy.
Depends on what we define as mainstream.
Are we talking about bands that are famous, or bands that are ***d out like the Jonas Brothers?
owensp wrote:i think that yes, mainstream can ruin a genre. rock has been ruined in my opinion. in the 70's, rock was about melodies and harmonies and the songs had alot of meaning to them(this was mainstream then)Eric Clapton "Roll it Over": "Go down easy and let me take my time. Go down easy and let me take my time. Rock me slow till I lose my mind. Roll it over, let's take it from behind. Roll it over, let's take it from behind. It's only love, God knows it ain't no crime" It's not deep at all. It's about having sex. Of course, Clapton is an excellent guitarist, and he did have a lot of deeper songs, but it's no different than any mainstream song now. EDIT: John Mayer is a pretty good guitarist, and he's mainstream: Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6sPmTgPvx28 Even though he dresses like a total tool (two popped collars?), he shows good skill.
Nightmare wrote:what! no. opeth is progressive death metalYou are somewhat correct, they are a progressive black/death metal Quote from my Guitar World magazine interview with Opeth: 'Even though we were part of the Black Metal scene, I didn't feel like we really belonged to it; we were more like hippies'-Mikael Akerfeldt But yeah I'm not a massive fan of them so I won't argue anymore about it. That was a pretty nice, improv?, then...kind of SRV influnced.
I agree there arn't many modern rock guitarists who display much talent. Maybe because the band they are in wants the focus to be the pop aspect of rock, so the singing and chord progressions. However, John Mayer, whom I use to dislike, I now respect and see him as a blues player. He is a decent guitarist, hell probably better than me. He does blues more than pop now, he even says he hates the poppy aspect of rock. Its on youtube in an interview.
I would argue that most modern rock music now days are focusing on expression rather than technical ability. Look at The White Stripes, The Black Keys, going back tom and rage aginst the machine. Tom is one of the most expressive and experimental guitarist I've ever heard. What about Les Claypool of Primus, a very cool, good, yet unique band.
I'll take unique and expressive anyway over some technical shredder masturbating on the fretboard any day.
John Mayer is talented but lacks than self expression. He came out a Dave Matthews want-to-be and today is a SRV want-to-be.
Look it's tough to make a living in music and sometimes you have to "sell" to the consumer. beside if you don't like it don't buy it or should i say pirate it.
Zakk Wylde, Kirk Hammett, and Slash. All mainstream. All classified at the VMAs as hard ROCK.
hammett?? no offense but he dosen't put a scratch on Mustaine, I love both of them but Mustaine was just more...solid and flowy.
Anyway enough fanboy-ism.
'Rock' these days is getting to confused with metal, its beginning to annoy me personally, like Zeppelin (yes I can't spell it shame on me) is rock to me where as Metallica is metal,
So Page is a rock musician and Hammitt is a metal musician...though they can overlap yes.
'Nutter166, ah okay good to know, but i never heard anything for opeth that is black metal. I'm not also a massive fan of opeth, although they're not bad, master apprentice is my favorite.
'owensp well okay if u dont want to consider metal as a mainstream, heres some rock, alt. ,punk, etc.(mainstream) bands with good guitarists :
-Muse(who jcb3000 already mentioned)
-Airbourne
-Breaking Benjamin
-Escape the Fate
-Matchbook Romance
-Red Hot Chili Peppers (already mentioned)
-Rock n' Roll Soldiers
-Wolfmother
-Arctic Monkeys
and much more.. if u want some metal too just tell me, it'll be a long list though
note : a good guitarist isn't only a fast guitarist or a good sweeper,but also a creative guitarist who play good music.
For me a great guitarist would be able to play technically but with emotion yet not blatantly ripping someone else off, bit hard to do I know, theres always parts of your insperation coming through.
I wonder how I forgot John Mayer. Well, as others have said he is a good, possibly great player, but not necessarily hyper-creative. I would generally consider him a "true" artist, though. I think he really cares about what he's doing.
Nutter166 wrote:hammett?? no offense but he dosen't put a scratch on Mustaine, I love both of them but Mustaine was just more...solid and flowy. Anyway enough fanboy-ism. 'Rock' these days is getting to confused with metal, its beginning to annoy me personally, like Zeppelin (yes I can't spell it shame on me) is rock to me where as Metallica is metal, So Page is a rock musician and Hammitt is a metal musician...though they can overlap yes.Oh crap, yeah Mustaine kicks ass. My fav at the moment too. Man I had a brain fart. =p
Nightmare wrote:owensp well okay if u dont want to consider metal as a mainstreammetal isnt mainstream. just accept it. mainstream music is played on tv and the radio. most metal isnt. notice i said MOST metal. yes some metal is mainstream but not very much of it.
And any metal that is mainstream is not good metal either in my opinion. Even bands like Judas Priest, Metallica, Sabbath, and so on were'nt as good as their earlier stuff. If it's on the radio then it's tends to be poppy and not dark, evil, bad, whatever you want to call it, enough. It's not to say that a guitarist that has music on the radio is not quality, it's just not as interesting.