Where are all the good guitarists nowadays?
Megadeth will **in' rock ya man! I love them.
MUSTAINE 4 PRESIDENT!!!!!!
Ozz
aren't Bullet for My Valentine a mainstream? or how about Korn? Metallica are not a mainstream!!! and arent there some Rap Metal bands too??!!
Metallica is mainstream dude, at least in the states they are. They have radio, tv, MTV, and there was even a documentary on them in 'O1.
ya i know that Ozz, tell them.
At one point in the late 80's or early 90's we were hearing "Shred is dead". That's when the public decided they wanted to hear more aleternative, pop, hip hop, rap, crap, whatever you want to call it but definetly nothing interesting.
So, at one time, you can listen to the radio and hear metal or rock bands that played music with solos that sometimes went on forever. If you want to hear that stuff now, you have to go to the internet to find em, hear them, talk about em. At least we have that.
However, fusion was never really on the radio anyways and that's were you can find all the great guitarists. All of the greats are still out there producing music and touring and there are a lot of internet sites, like this one, where you can hear about them. Al DiMeola, John McLauglin, Scott Henderson, Frank Gambale, Allan Holdsworth, Shawn Lane (he's dead but the music is alive), John Scofield. There's a great German band called the Jazz Pistols. Check them out!
No matter how you look at it, music is never going to be what it was in the past. You can say the best is behind us, but in reality, all that is doing is causing us to turn a blind eye to anything new.
If this is an expressive vs technical issue, I'd have to go with expressive. Just because a musician is more focused on their expression then their technical ability doesn't mean they don't know what they are doing.
I'm constantly being impressed by new guitarists and new bands. Yet, I'm also equally dismayed at the same time. There are a lot of crappy bands out there that don't get it. YOu can have someone who emulates the music of the past; and may be one of the best out there, but if he isn't expressive, it's nothing new to me.
@ Nightmare - Oh sorry man, I thought YOU said that they were mainstream. srry man.
@ Brody - Its good that music won't be the same, it needs to change, it'll get boring pretty fast if we go back to big hair and look-to-be *** rights activists dancing around a stage with pin mic stands in ricockulous poses. It was cool, its not now, cept some of their music, but most was just a copy-cat of the original.
brodyxhollow wrote:If this is an expressive vs technical issue, I'd have to go with expressive. Just because a musician is more focused on their expression then their technical ability doesn't mean they don't know what they are doing.yes, but most music on the radio today isnt expressive. its just some moron singing about how he doesnt fit in at school or some girl singing about getting banged... well since some Slipknot is played on the radio i must say that Mick and James are the only guitarists on the radio that can "Shred" that ive heard. idk about people in the states tho.
theres Vinnie Paul's band Hellyeah, their guitarist isn't the most technical, but definetly good on the expressive end of things.
Fair enough if you know what your doing you can find anything on the radio, I've listen to Dream Theater, BFMV, Megadeth, Atreyu, Classic Sabbath (Into The Void, Symptom of the Universe, the good stuff :P), LZ and such on the radio mixed togther.
Its all just a matter of finding your station, or the time on the station. Hell you could always just try sending in a request for them, my step-dad sent in a request for Into the Void on Radio1 in the middle of the day and got it played.
When will ignorant people stop making absurd claims about the lack of good, popular musicians when they have no qualification to do so?
If you listen a bit closer, you'll find plenty. I'm going to bet that most of these guitarists in mainstream rock are better than most of us here anyway.
No doubt there Doz :P There will always be complaints about people saying theres no new 'good' guitarists, no why round it sadly =[
Damn right Doz, well said.
Tru Dat Doz.
Biffy Clyro...
Is a band, the guitarist is Simon Neil, good band though and good guitar as well =]
I'm qualified: I'm 45, Iv'e been playing since I was about 13, I've lived in the L.A./Hollywood area all my life where I've seen countless bands and musicians, I've been in two reasonably successful bands myself, I played a blues gig for a week on Bourbon Street in New Orleans when I was about 27, I have a collection of music on vinyl, 8 track, cassett tapes, from punk to funk that dates back to 1969 most of wich I bought myself when new, I studied music history and guitar in college....I could go on and on.
Trust me. The music that's played on the radio today is not nearly as good as it was in the 70's, 80's and even the 90's. I'm not saying there are'nt any great new musicians out there now, they're just not doing anything new.
And, I'm not one of those old guys with a closed mind. I'd love to hear about a band with a great new guitar player that's doing something so different and new, it blows me a away and I have to tell everybody about it. Like when my friend Lance told me that I have to go to his house after school and listen to this guy. He put on the album and what I heard was unbelievable! It was Eruption from Eddie Van Halen in 1978. I don't think I'll ever have a moment like that again.
"Ignorant" is being young and unexperienced and making claims you know what music was like at a time you did'nt even exist and have the balls to compare it todays music.
ROCK NEEDS TO GO THROUGH A PROGRESSIVE PHASE.
owensp wrote:ROCK NEEDS TO GO THROUGH A PROGRESSIVE PHASE.Like Prog. Rock? Check out the band "Tool". They are considered "prog" and they get plenty of air time on the two main rock stations in my area.
O.K. I won't just ****. I'll contribute. Umphrey's McGee is a band I found on the net. They are an excellent jam band with two excellent guitarists. They are like a modern day progressive rock band like Steely Dan but beyond.
If your serious about "new" good guitarists, you gotta check them out. http://www.umphreys.com
Their site has a whole bunch of free stuff to keep you busy for days.
This band is filled with excellent players. Band is called Protest the Hero. Recently heard them and freaked at their awesome-ness. Some people may be distracted by vocals when first hearing them so here is the instrumental version of one of their songs off their newest album, Fortress.
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=44UdSILe74I
I'm so not into that, I listened to a whole 7 seconds before i hit the stop button.
GRX40 wrote:Like Prog. Rock? Check out the band "Tool". They are considered "prog" and they get plenty of air time on the two main rock stations in my area.when i say pregressive rock i mean someone needs to do something TOTALLY different. but it should be something thats not a dead end. it should be something that could influence others to make something like it but a little different(thats what you call influential music and there is NO influential music being made right now). then someone else will take THAT and make something else out of it. that is progressive
yea i love pth
Check out the band Porcupine Tree, they are a prog rock/metal/psychedelic band from the UK. I think they're quite big in the states and in Europe, but they are quite small in the UK still. This is one of their most accessible songs:
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fTNO4PBO5Zo
macandkanga: Ignorant doesn't mean young and enexperienced, really. It can mean shallow and closed minded. And OK, you're 45. You've done all of that. How do we know you get it? We don't know how good you are at guitar? How do we know how good that gig actually went? How do we know that your taste just isn't bad?
I'm not saying it is, my point is that you may be qualified to tell yourself, but you still aren't qualified to tell anyone else, because you can't prove yourself a judge of modern guitarists.
I have to say, marsdemartini: Protest the Hero is full of brilliant players, and we just witnessed a person (telecrater) judge the quality based on music taste, which is subjective. I'm not saying he did it wrongly, but I'm saying he's missing some skilled and intense music because he doesn't really go for that type of sound. Some people do go for the sound, so it's fair to say that the only person you can judge this to is yourself.
Doz, you are absolutely right. I kinda went off yesterday! And I am sorry if I insulted you or anyone else. I guess it's because I am very passionate about the music of my time. Actually, the gig in New Orleans was horrible and I sucked out loud! I just like to tell people I did it! To boot, in college I learned a lot about theory but was so high I forgot most of it! To this day, I still can't read music by sight! I have always played by ear and obvliously I can read tab. I actually don't really have any other substantial talents except being a good husband and father and playing the guitar. I am actually pretty good. One day I'll put something up so you can see I'm not lying.
Anyways, I appologize again for being a tool. But seriouslly check out Umphrey's McGee. They are as different as they get nowdays and really good!
I took another listen to Protest the Hero. It was very well orchestrated and but i don't think it'll listen to it again. I don't enjoy that music any more.
On the other hand Umphrey's McGee, i checked out a song they hand on their site and i really dug it. I'm going to check out some of their other stuff. Thanks for the recommendation.
Nah, no offence taken or anything, you didn't say anything negative against me so don't worry. It's just a really grey and debatable area in music. Actually, most topics on music are.
I try to keep an open mind but there are some types of music I just don't like. To each his own I guess, if everyone liked the same thing music would be kinda boring. Five minutes ago I was jamin to hootie & the blowfish ; )
someone needs to do something different. its all the same
want something different?
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FTCjEc2C6aI
some people are way too subjective when it comes to music. there with always be people that disagree so the most suitable answer to the question "where are all the good guitarists nowadays?" is no where yet everywhere. it just depends on who you consider to be a good guitarist.
@bodom
i wonder what their band practice is like jeez.
and that guy with the tea cozy on his head has a micro korg, those things are amazing!
yeah i agree it all depends on personal preference. but this is my opinion and my personal preference and im wondering what other people's are
Bodom, that was freaking awesome.
I can't embed this (by request), but I hope you guys still check it out:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xRDG9GKb-TM
It's The Mars Volta playing their song "Goliath," it has a really nice groove and some plain crazy stuff going on. These guys are absolutely fantastic live, I might add :)
Crunch wrote:Bodom that was freaking awesome. I can't embed this (by request), but I hope you guys still check it out: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xRDG9GKb-TM It's The Mars Volta playing their song "Goliath," it has a really nice groove and some plain crazy stuff going on. These guys are absolutely fantastic live, I might add :)That verse riff really reminds me of something the Rage Against the Machine would do. Which is kind of weird, since RATM's lead vocalist teamed up with the Mars Volta's drummer and released some songs.
Yeah i hear bomb track on that tune.
I was pretty excited to hear that The Mars Volta's "L'Via L'Viaquez" is on the new Guitar Hero. Now I'm just waiting for one of my friends to buy the damned thing :)
blackholesun wrote:Check out the band Porcupine Tree, they are a prog rock/metal...Actually Porcupine Tree are one of the worst band i ever heard, seriously.
And why do you think that?
Like I said, it is one of their poppiest, more accessible songs. Bearing in mind that legends like Alex Lifeson (Rush), Robert Fripp (King Crimson) and Mikael Åkerfeldt (Opeth) have guested on their last two albums, it shows the impact that they have in the prog rock/metal genre.
Nightmare: You can't just state opinion without evidance, or explanation, in a debate. It just makes you look ignorant even if there are reasons you said it.
Remember that music is an art form. Look at the video BodomBeachTerror posted for example. it was very artistic and full of self expression though not something i typically enjoy and can respect in it.
Just because you don't like something does not mean it's crap or the worst band ever.
Look at the music of the late 80's and 90's. Nirvana and many other bands were able to express them selves with 4 over driven chords and that took over mainstream rock. was nirvana the worst band in the world? some would say so, others would argue not.
Regardless music is about self expression. If you don't like something that's fine. But come on share with us why you don't like it.
Nightmare wrote:Actually Porcupine Tree are one of the worst band i ever heard, seriouslyActually i like Porcupine Tree, especially Trains, Blackest Eyes and Lazarus.... In fact, Blackwater Park album of Opeth was produced by Porcupine Tree frontman Steve Wilson
I think he did Deliverance and Damnation by Opeth as well. I think my favorite Porcupine Tree song is Anesthetize, but it's 18 minutes long which is too long for a standard youtube video, hence the two-parter:
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1GzSTT2T4V8
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e-y8MSqhfB8
Their early stuff like The Sky Moves Sideways is pretty cool as well. Really good for just chilling out.
telecrater wrote:Just because you don't like something does not mean it's crap or the worst band ever.I said it's the worst band i ever heard, and what i said refers to my OPINION. 'Doz when someone says that he/she thinks that band sux, it simply means that he/she doesn't like how the band sounds. Anyways u wanna know why i think PT suck, it's because i dont like their Psychedelic rock/metal songs. It's like listening to Pantera with Pink Floyd vocal. Having Mikael Åkerfeldt a guest on PT last two albums, means only that a good guitarist played with them, but he played different style in a different genre. Cannibal Corpse's(Brutal/Death Metal) guitarist used to play with Nevermore(Heavy Metal), but does it mean that who ever like Nevermore should like Cannibal Corpse, or should the two bands be really good? No, each band got their own music style and their own fans. Same goes for Chris Broderick.
Doz wrote:Nightmare: You can't just state opinion without evidance, or explanation, in a debate. It just makes you look ignorant even if there are reasons you said it.AGREED nightmare seems to do that alot
owensp wrote:AGREED nightmare seems to do that alotreally i do that alot? ok next time i'll try to be more reasonable, but if didnt mention any evidance or didnt state any reason doesn't mean im ignorant, it's just that i find it hard to explain so i would rather not to type anything.
Can you really say they're the worst band you've heard though, Nightmare? I don't think so.
No, but if you asked me who's the best band you ever heard, i could not have answered that question too.
Nightmare wrote:when someone says that he/she thinks that band sux, it simply means that he/she doesn't like how the band sounds.Yeah, if you're in first school and you can't think of a proper adjective to use. It's fair enough if you don't like their sound but that doesn't mean they automatically "suck" and they're "the worst band ever". PT sound nothing like Pantera, and since when have clean vocals been a bad thing? I didn't say that PT are good simply because Opeth's guitarist played on an album, or that Opeth fans would automatically like PT. I was saying that it shows that Porcupine Tree have respect from many artists in the prog rock genre, which indirectly shows that they are good because if they weren't then people like Åkerfeldt, Fripp and Lifeson wouldn't be interested in playing on their albums.