Should The mod on this site censor anything he deams offensive;innapropriate; etc.?
he CAN, but he does not have the right to. cops CAN beat a black person senseless and then plant crack on them, but they don't have the right to. NO ONE has the right to tell someone what to and not to say, under ANY CIRCUMSTANCES. PERIOD.
baudelaire shut the f@ck up Im sick of you. You are so pin eyed it isnt funny.
what, getting a little hot under the collar when freedom doesn't necessarily swing your way? i like your concise argument, by the way. very rational.
baudelaire wrote:he CAN, but he does not have the right to. cops CAN beat a black person senseless and then plant crack on them, but they don't have the right to. NO ONE has the right to tell someone what to and not to say, under ANY CIRCUMSTANCES. PERIOD.Why bring race into this? why did you post "beat a black person" is it not unlawful for a cop to beat anyone senseless, regardless of race, sex or creed. are you raciest? Besides if he really disenfranchised you or anyone else why don't you call a civil rights lawyer. I really want to hear him laugh at you. If fact please do record it, I want it to be my new ring tone.
nice try tele, but i think it's obvious why i said black person. because cops are ten times more likely to beat a black person and say they had drugs/a weapon then they are a white person. and they virtually ALWAYS get away with beating blacks, but whites have a chance.
i know, you finally thought you saw a chink in my armor. "that's it", you said, "i'll try to label him a racist! for saying things a racist would deny! oh, shoot, maybe i should have thought that one through better..."
and if i was really disenfranchised, i'd just DDOS the site... but i'm not that upset or that much of a ***, and i really like the site. besides, no real damage has been done to me, all i could manage to legally get was an apology.
Depends on what's said. If someone is spewing some hate speech on another race, culture, etc. then it should be censored.
If it's a disagreement about politics and what not, then it shouldn't be censored.
For all of those who say "STOP THE CENSORSHIP!1!! ZOMG1!!", please remember that here is a line between good and evil.
hate speech shouldn't be censored. what if you're a racist? you still have the same rights as everyone else. freedom swings both ways. it can be dangerous, and it can be disturbing, but "he whom would trade a measure of safety for a measure of freedom deserves, and will recieve, neither" -benjamin franklin. "i may disagree with what you have to say, but i will defend to the death your right to say it" -voltaire.
there IS no line at which a right should cease to be exercised; even if it means people get hurt. the KKK has as much right to say what they want to say as the negro college fund organization thing has.
sweet mother of cheese!!! every1 stop being so disagreeable!!!
BodomBeachTerror wrote:sweet mother of cheese!!! every1 stop being so disagreeable!!!I LOVE CHEESE TOO!!!!!! lol. Seriously though, I'm never posting any of this **** again, even I'm tired of it.
ok fine baudelaire you win, your superior intellect and got me speechless, I just don't know what to say. So i bow down to you sand mutter these words...
I'm not worthy, I'm not worthy.
that's better!
People like Baud are disgusting. They don't care if someone spreads love or hate, as long as they have the right to do so.
Let's make one thing clear: Hate is not something that should ever be allowed.
I seriously wonder if people like Baud can tell the difference between love and hate.
EDIT: And just because Benjamin Franklin said it doesn't mean it's right
why oh why bring race into this? this is getting seriously blown out of proportion. and do you believe you can go around calling people hurtfull things just because you have the right? use that right dont abuse it. if you do then that makes you some sort of intolerant verbal sadist. might not be the right words there but i get what i mean.
I think Admin (as it's his/her site) should make it quite clear what constitutes good and bad behaviour on the site.
I also think he/she should take necessary steps to remove continual trouble makers who might well be 'frightening off' quieter and perhaps more thoughtful members of the site by their overbearing behaviour.
In this way, the site might get back to what it was in the first place. A damn good place to learn guitar and get descent advice and encouragement!
yes.
If you are not allowed to hate, you are not allowed to love, either. it's not a decision if you don't have a choice.if you choose to outlaw hatred from those that would express it, eventually love will outlawed as well. this is a pattern that every single tyrannical regime has followed through history; and it all starts with weak minded people that want someone else to protect them from free people, because people that use their freedoms scare and offend most people. Hate MUST be allowed - because you can never ban, 'just a few words'. the government will always take MORE and MORE.
yes, freedom is more important to me then safety, peace, or love. it's incomprehensible that it should be any other way. you can't define them anyways - to say that what you think is love is the only definition is narrow minded. what someone does, you may call hate, but they may call love. you, and no one else, admin or president, has the right to force THEIR MIND onto someone ELSES. this is why the KKK, the communists, the anarchists, the black panthers, the zionists, the american mujahideen, the Militia, this is why they have the right to exist - because just because YOU disagree, doesn't give you the right to CONDEMN and IMPRISON people that don't think JUST LIKE YOU.
and sixtiesguy? shutup - because i contribute more then you when the subject is on topic. people just become aghast when the subject goes off topic, and i defend myself instead of just mimicking everyone else. and i rarely ever TAKE it off topic. i can understand why your reaction would be to kill off the people that are different - you live in britain, where everyone peacefully accepted complete government surveillance, don't give a ** about your freedom, and oftentimes actually buy into the ridiculous propoganda they give you guys over there in Airstrip One.
I have an idea.
Everyone just ignore baudelaire. Just dont comment on his posts.
baudelaire: There are no rights on the internet.
In order for their to be rights on the internet, it needs to be united under a common law. When you create law, you restrict the rights of the users.
Please prove a reliable source that proclaims that there are such rights on the internet.
Bodom said:-
I have an idea.
Everyone just ignore baudelaire. Just dont comment on his posts.
Exactly what I proposed in a different thread when 'soap box sid' was getting on his high horse yet again! Take away his oxygen and you'll snuff out the flame.
"There's a fine line between love and hate"
I don't think they're forcefully taking our freedom of speech away... just sort of ... blocking it. But some things are understandable to remove though, like someone saying "I ****ed your mom, you little B****". Though, everyone gets their own individual kicks out of something.
Eh, England's a disgrace to live in now, to be honest... There was some rule that was "supposed" to have come out saying we weren't allowed to show our own flag out our windows, or cars or pubs because it was racist to muslims. Thankfully, the second everyone started hearing this, we all started wearing our flag.
Though, it sickens me that something like that even came about. We can't even be proud for our own country anymore.
Since you were speaking of China... did you know that if you spit on the streets you spend the night in prison? Along with a massive fine.
Harsh country... might live there one day.
like i said in my previous post, this is being blown way out of proportion to what it actually is. THIS IS A SMALL WEBSITE NOT A NATIONAL GOVERNMENT. who really actually cares that a couple of pointless posts got deleted in the first place? because this is what it's really about, not human rights and laws. main reasons why posts get deleted is because it is A)offensive to other people and B)pointless spamming. if this was not the case we would see this, what i must say is a brilliant site, turn into a ***hole like UG. just cut the crap with the whole moderator business and learn about and play on you bloody guitars.
ATTENTION ADMIN !!!
Since the majority of us appear to be singing from the same hymn sheet, can we please have a directive or initiative to prevent further damage to this most excellent guitar website that YOU created?
justjeff: rights are not given by any law. rights are 'self evident', and born with every human. the law serves us, we do not serve the law. if the police came to burn your books, would you let them, just because it's the law, or would you shoot them/hide the books?
and yeah, sure it's nothing but a useful little website, but as long as we're discussing it, why not discuss it thoroughly? no one makes you read ANYTHING here, open ANY thread, or make ANY response!!!
and be more mature, too. don't get all pissy. if you don't like something, ignore it. if you A) don't agree with me and B) don't have a reasonable argument then just don't say anything, instead of hooting and hollering about how much you dislike me.
What would I do? I would hide them: Not because it is my right to keep them, but because I WANT to keep them.
There is a difference between what a right IS and what a right OUGHT to be.
You say that rights are self-evident, god given, and inalienable, however none of these are true. I will tackle the following one by one.
Self Evident Rights: Well, this one is sort of easy to follow. If a right was held to be self-evident, why are we fighting over it? Self evident is defined by dictionary.com as "evident in itself without proof or demonstration; axiomatic". If it is so evident without proof, why do we not all agree on this fact? Why are there countries that deny the rights that we have outlined as self-evident?
God-Given Rights: You will very rarely ever find a right that is described in the bible as something that we hold true today. Most rights described in the bible include slavery, and the Torah says it's okay to kill your children if they disrespected you. And if rights were so god-given, why did Judeo-christian culture start with theocracy, then move to monarchy, both of which are dictatorship? Many of the laws enacted by these dictatorships would cry human right abuse.
Inalienable: In order for rights to be inalienable (not alienable; not transferable to another or capable of being repudiated: inalienable rights, synonym is absolute), as defined, should not be able to be repudiated. However, many governments and organizations have restricted, or completely removed such rights from the people of the nation. So therefore, you cannot claim that the right is inalienable.
Now, by proving that your statement of rights being self-evident, inalienable, and god-given, as being wrong, we can now state that none of these are true. The fact that we are arguing about such a statement shows that they are not defined correctly.
Now, I am a libertarian, and I believe in the rights of the people, not because they are god-given or inalienable, but because that's how things OUGHT to be. There is a huge difference.
laws change, rights don't. the law OUGHT to support the right, it might not. but the right never changed, it was just criminalized to exercise it.
i only claimed rights are self evident; there really being only one right, that to do as you wish so long as you don't prevent others from doing so as well. as for why others may not believe so, i don't care - they are taught that way by societies and governments that prefer their own power and wealth to the good of mankind. but the belief that man ought to be free, in the greatest sense of the word, regardless of the power of tyrants and oppressive society, is self-evidently logically unassailable. and this imperative has occured in every culture even moderately advanced, even restrictive ones.
as for god given, one might say that god as a form of supernatural higher morality native to man might be considered to have 'given us' these rights. but not god in the sense of any religious figure of omnipotence, certainly not a specifically judeo-christian one. but the greatest moral imperative man has is to freedom, and freedom in this sense is a human construct. god is also a human construct, (probably), so it could indeed be termed as 'god given'.
inalienable? yes, it is. it can only be given away, not taken. when they threaten you with imprisonment if you don't surrender your books, you still have the option to fight to the death... we always have that option. give me liberty, or give me death... one of those is always possible. i will have my books, because i have the right to them, and if they tried taking them away, it would be my choice to either surrender my right to books, or to load my shotgun and die for my books.
they are indeed all of the above: self evident, 'god' given, and inalienable. you are making the mistake in this: our right's are IDEALS, they do not change. what is enforced and accepted change... but in china, in soviet russia, 200 years from now when earth is a cyberpunk dystopia, the IDEAL will still exist... man will still have the choice between freedom and death, so long as he is man. the laws OUGHT to defend our rights, but when they don't, the rights still exist, they merely become more dangerous to exercise.
Your right every one else is wrong. Need we say more?Not trying to be a prick but it is going to come out that way so what the hell. baudelaire you are an ass. this was an awesome site and you have destroyed it. I come here to talk to guitarists about music but always get caught up in some off topic bull *** arguing. It has become a huge waist of time. You slam everything you don't like including music from beginners which is just being a massive prick. I get a bad vibe every time I log in. There is no difference from this site and UG. I'm out. I will check in from time to time but I won't be active on this site until this stupid *** stops.
To the Admin:
Truly hate to leave a site with such great potential you have done a great job. I really hope thing turn around and you get your "guitar" site back.
To all my friends on this site:
I hope the best for you all.
Later,
Later, Paul.
yea this site was really awesome.. i dont even read most of the posts now, knowing theyre pointless
Yeah. Look what you did, Phip...
Not trying to be a prick but it is going to come out that way so what the hell. baudelaire you are an ass.thanks.
this was an awesome site and you have destroyed it.i agree it's a great site. but i didn't do anything but talk on it. i never spammed, or made BS threads, or even insulted anyone personally without good cause.
I come here to talk to guitarists about music but always get caught up in some off topic bull *** arguingand? did i stop you? did i make you get caught up in something not directed at you anyways? no.
It has become a huge waist of time.if you wanted to talk about something, make a thread. did you? and if you did - did it get ignored? if not, nothing has changed.
You slam everything you don't like including music from beginners which is just being a massive prick.of course i do, and why not? beethovens father beat him. there is no gain without pain. self confidence and contentment are what kill off artists early, or make them **ty artists. a artist has to hate themselves and their work enough to keep trying to make better art, or they will fail. it's called motivation, and only negative motivation will create something meaningful.
get a bad vibe every time I log inoh lawdy not the vibes.
There is no difference from this site and UG.then flip a coin.
I'm out. I will check in from time to time but I won't be active on this site until this stupid *** stops.oh well.
To the Admin: Truly hate to leave a site with such great potential and really hope thing turn around and you get your "guitar" site back.the tools are what set it apart, the forum is nothing special.
TheAmericanBrit wrote:Yeah. Look what you did, Phip...lol at least i get a kick out of phips poinltessness.. all this political crap is just stupid..
Admin created a hell of a site and he has the right to do with it as he pleases. I am sorry to hear of all those whom feel the need to have Admin censor your dialogues. Here are some other quotes that are not Ben Franklin. Should they be ignored b/c they are not quite ambassadors to France as Ben was? Food for thought.
"We can never be sure that the opinion we are endeavoring to stifle is a false opinion; and if we were sure, stifling it would be an evil still." ~John Stuart Mill, On Liberty, 1859
"The only valid censorship of ideas is the right of people not to listen." ~Tommy Smothers
"Censorship reflects society's lack of confidence in itself. It is a hallmark of an authoritarian regime." ~Potter Stewart
"We have a natural right to make use of our pens as of our tongue, at our peril, risk and hazard." ~Voltaire
"The dirtiest book of all is the expurgated book." ~Walt Whitman
Far off musical topics, but someone might be willing to parlay this argument into a song.
baudelaire wrote:the tools are what set it apart, the forum is nothing special.They why the F$*k do you participate? You know what I'm outta of hear too. If anyone want's to get in touch with me you can PM me i'll keep an eye on that for a while maybe, then again maybe not. Latter Ladies and Gents
why not? it's cozy.
Guess the girls over at UG got bored, haha!
And so the playground bullies win again!