Should The mod on this site censor anything he deams offensive;innapropriate; etc.?
Poll: Should The mod on this site censor anything he deams offensive;innapropriate; etc.?
- No 8
- Yes 17
- Not Sure 0
- No 4
- Let the site users decide 2
a person that will censor others, for any reason - whether it be they disagree with them, they believe their words to be inappropriate, whether it offends, regardless - a person that will censor another person has inside of them a sort of disgusting arrogance, or a petulant, childish weakness. if it is the former, it is because they feel themselves superior so that they believe they have the right to tell another man what to say. if it is the latter, it is because they are emotionally fragile, and instead of maturely handling it, by ignoring it, they lash out like a empowered child, and close someone elses mouth because they can't handle whatever it is they said.
there is at no level of authority the right to censor someones words; the government does not have that right, the internet providers do not have that right, the schools and churches and parents and webmasters and moderators and business owners and police officers and politicians do not have that right.
Thank you, finally something we can agree on.
Damn straight Baudelaire...
"We're not going to protest!!!" PCU
i say it matters what users say, i think some 1 who makes a thread should have power to edit/ delete posts on it.
I have decided that this Poll will end Teusday so vote up.
Sorry, it just needs to end sometime so it won't get forgotten a left aside.
Just a thought (if I may). This site is not a democracy. it is the work and property of the creator (the admin). It's his site and it's his call. we have no "rights" here. we are guests.
Am i for free speech? yes
Am i for a little common courtesy? yes please
"I have decided ". oh really? that's nice skippy.
Phip
i agree with phip
the admin dos a gr8 job, only thing tht would be nice is power over ur own thread, at least to delete comments, doesnt mean the admin cant delete stuff too, just kinda gives more control to stay on topic.
but then you could delete any critisism..
Phip wrote:Just a thought (if I may). This site is not a democracy. it is the work and property of the creator (the admin). It's his site and it's his call. we have no "rights" here. we are guests. Am i for free speech? yes Am i for a little common courtesy? yes please "I have decided ". oh really? that's nice skippy. Phip1. Skippy? Really? lol. 2. And all I ment by that is that I'll take in all the votes that have been made on Tuesday, not that you can't still vote or post, I mean the thread isn't going to disappear man.
phip, it does not matter if it's his site; he does not have the authority to tell you what to say and not to say. he has the power to do so; but not the authority. a self evident super-natural human right is inviolable, period. if i was in his house, he STILL would not have the right to tell me what to say... he'd have the right to tell me to leave or force me off his property, but if you think he has the authority to tell me what to say, does that mean he has the authority to deny my right to live? they are both just as inviolable as the other, whats the difference?
the idea that 'appropriateness' and 'courtesy' and 'political correctness' have any place in determining what one may say is a heinous LIE, perpetrated by people that would WELCOME a tyranny, a rule of law where one may only say what the powerful deem to be safe, where one may only say what the idiot mobs of humanity will not take offense too. where you have the right to say what others accept... what is the use of such a right?
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M6Col-Ryj44
why would u want to, unless its like go fk urself, and its constructive y qould u delete?
@baud,
Yeah, i understand your point completly. My point in case i mistated it is that the admin has the right to delete anything he wants on this site because it is indeed HIS site. In other words, if I come into your house and offend you, you have the right to throw me out. that is all i am saying. In no way am i willing to acquiesce authority to anyone when it comes to any of my personal freedoms, much more so i believe, than many of my countrymen of late.
Having said that, I have no problem personally with "toning" down my language at times when i am in the presence of certain people whom i feel may be offended by my language. It's a personal choice that i exercise in order to show respect in some cases. I have no "authority" to "tell" others how to conduct themselves but at times I do have the strong urge to "suggest" a kinder "tone" or use of language out of respect for other members. I don't count courtesy as one of my weaknesses but rather a strength born out of maturity.
Phip
it's not a big deal anyways, but i believe that he has the right to delete things like spam. it's not speech, it's just a form of flooding to piss people off. but to delete someones words because he disagrees with them, i believe that is overstepping his bounds.
baudelaire wrote:it's not a big deal anyways, but i believe that he has the right to delete things like spam. it's not speech, it's just a form of flooding to piss people off. but to delete someones words because he disagrees with them, i believe that is overstepping his bounds.That's what pissed me off, he deleted my song I wrote. I know it was dumb but it was joke to lighten up someone's day [someone thats not Miley Cyrus, Corey Taylor, or the Jonas Brothers lol] and he went and deleted the whole post. No spam at all.
deleting someones words because you disagree with them would be at best unwise. the free flow of ideas is important. for me this poll (i think) is about the use of excessive profanity, and by that i mean profanity that goes far beyond expressing a point of view. Profanity for the sake of profanity. I read a post (i think it was yesterday) and i thouht George Carlin was back from the dead. Attention getting profanity. it was foolishness. Hell, (oops) i didn't have any problem with your rather colorful description of the new pedal you recently aquired because i can relate to the elation you described.
Look, when i joined this forum last year it was a great place to exchange ideas and knowledge, and yes there was a certain amount of goofing around and plenty of swearing, but not like it has been of late. Some of the elder regulars have stopped joining in but I think that decision was ill advised. I'm sticking around because i want to learn and one day contribute something of what i have learned to others. The rudeness and "shock jocks" may come and some may go but in the end this forum was established to benefit those who want to share their love of music and the guitar and they are the ones that will prevail. Geez you don't get enough crap in the outside world you gotta come in here and spred your disease? cover your freaking mouth when you cough! (not directed at any specific individual...yet)
Phip
EMB5490 wrote:why would u want to, unless its like go fk urself, and its constructive y qould u delete?cuz some ppl are stupid and think theyre the best and cant improve? idk when i got here there was VERY little swearing
Phip wrote:deleting someones words because you disagree with them would be at best unwise. the free flow of ideas is important. for me this poll (i think) is about the use of excessive profanity, and by that i mean profanity that goes far beyond expressing a point of view. Profanity for the sake of profanity. I read a post (i think it was yesterday) and i thouht George Carlin was back from the dead. Attention getting profanity. it was foolishness. Hell, (oops) i didn't have any problem with your rather colorful description of the new pedal you recently aquired because i can relate to the elation you described. Look, when i joined this forum last year it was a great place to exchange ideas and knowledge, and yes there was a certain amount of goofing around and plenty of swearing, but not like it has been of late. Some of the elder regulars have stopped joining in but I think that decision was ill advised. I'm sticking around because i want to learn and one day contribute something of what i have learned to others. The rudeness and "shock jocks" may come and some may go but in the end this forum was established to benefit those who want to share their love of music and the guitar and they are the ones that will prevail. Geez you don't get enough crap in the outside world you gotta come in here and spred your disease? cover your freaking mouth when you cough! (not directed at any specific individual...yet) PhipHELL YEAH!!!!! lol. Sorry Phip, couldn't resist dude. And the profanity thing was mostly directed at me right? Yeah I know. Sorry If it offended you, although none of it was HARSHLY directed at anyone on this forum, it my post that got deleted was just joking around about some bands that are a bit overrated in my opinion. I respect YOU though, some not so much, and those of which do not need mentioning.
@ Ozzfan486,
Yeah, the profanity thing was directed at you, that's true, but much of the bulk of what i am going on about has been going on LONG before you arrived. So, don't assume i am getting on you case, just chill and enjoy the ride! It' about the music, why else would someone join this forum?
You know I don't want to sound like some old dude (yes is do) but BACK IN MY DAY music and musicians (most of them) were all about peace and love and ** like that. You younger guys, you're all about killing yourselfs and all kinds of negative stuff. you're generation must really be pissed off is all i can say! Is that going to be the motto of your generation? We're pissed so we're gonna kill ourselves, that'll show ya! You guys need to get a cause, ya know like global warming or something, write some songs, then peace out, make love and join a commune or something. worked for us!
Phip
lool i agree with Phip, our generation is pretty messed.. but you guys didnt have things like Halo, wish lead us to beleive killing is fun! lol
Yes the Admin has the right to delete peoples posts. Thats their Job! And it wasnt because he didnt disagree with it, it was probly because it was another stupid pointless post.... you know the kind of post that is killing this site.
Get ready for some censoring here:
baudelaire you are just douche bag. You are the type of person who likes to argue just to argue.This isnt about freedom of speach or a person who has too much power that went to their head. Its about keeping this site clean of very offense and useless material.
Oh god, believe me, I'm not gonna kill myself to teach someone a lesson, thats all the "Emo" bull**** thats going around, its just a scene thing, and all the things that get blamed on music are just stupid, EX. - Kid kills students at colloege, he owned an Ozzy cd so Ozzy will be accused, its stupid how fast the media just jumps to conclusions.
And sorry, but we can't really do what you guys did because then it was right and for a good cause but now its just because "Oh look at my new bell-bottoms peace" and then they get labeled "That dumb hippie faggot". Where you guys actually protested and made a signifigant difference in the world.
I can't speak for anyone else but I guess if I had to I'd be somewhat like Dave Mustaine, not all peace loving and the "Scene" guy but anti-government. And believe me, I watch the news and read the papers and everything has gone to **** with Bush these past eight years and as far as I can see its only going to get worse. You might as well just vote for the VP this fall because heres my guees of what will go down.
Obama - Assasinated by a KKK member.
McCain - Will probably die in office.
Its sad but to some extent it makes sense.
My music though is probably going to just be about life and what I think is going on with me, or a story of some sort that would make a nice storyline of a song.
sorry for the mini-auto-biographie,
Jake [aka Ozzfan]
Ozzfan486 wrote:and everything has gone to **** with Bush these past eight years and as far as I can see its only going to get worsew00t for Canada!
BodomBeachTerror wrote:w00t for Canada!Lucky..haha lol.
Yeah, the owner can do whatever they want with this site and that's the way it should be. Man, when I was growing up in the 70's we could give two shi*s about politics. We were too busy smoking weed and listening to music and doing nothing.
Ozzfan, if you're really 12....relaaaaax.
Nope, I'm actually 63 and chillin' in the Bahamas with my hot blonde wife, and I don't even play an instrument!!!
Rofl. Just jokin' man, I am really 12, I just think its bad not to be in touch with the world around you, I like to know whos going to *** with us next lol.
Ozzfan486 wrote:I like to know whos going to *** with us nextUmmm, that would be China, and the sad thing is we are inviting them right in the front door with our trade policies. Look out man (and learn to play a flute)!
Good man Ozzfan. Stay in touch. I'm not saying we were right. Things were just different then (I hate that I just said that. I am old).
Hey man, as long as you don't feel old don't worry about it, hell, I feel 21, I just can't have a pint of Jack at the local pub though lol.
If the Admin wants to delete your post your **ed!~ His site! If ya want to **** and wine go to OPrah..Man say what you have to say ....you still said it, if the admin wants to delete it ,its his site WTF,He's not stopping you from saying what you want, He's letting you say it and thinks it not for the site and deleting it.If you want to control a site .....make your own.
The point is, he shouldn't DELETE it. Bleep it out who cares you can still tell what the person said most of the time but total duct-tape across the mouth is for me intolerable.
Ozzfan486 wrote:And sorry, but we can't really do what you guys did because then it was right and for a good cause but now its just because "Oh look at my new bell-bottoms peace" and then they get labeled "That dumb hippie faggot". Where you guys actually protested and made a signifigant difference in the world.Ah, that's not true my young friend! you DO have a cause. The planet is melting and the whole world is going down the environmental flusher! Is anyone today writing music about this? I'm a bit out of touch i'll admit but global warming; that's your vietnam war right there! there's a lot of room for some great music to be made about this. Yes/No? Phip
I don't know if I'd compare it to Vietnam but you do have a great point. I'll start thinking up lyrics. We need more "Will you like my lollipop" in some wierd star wars droid voice in the music industry anyways haha.
It's BIGGER THAN NAM. we're talking about the whole human race in peril. listen to eve of destruction by Barry McGuire and Mercy Mercy Me by Marvin ***e. We started then and now it's time for your generation to carry on. great cause, great opportunity to make a difference and a reputation. here, i'll get you started. Who's killing your mother (mother earth) who gave you life blah blah blah etc.
Be the first, be the best,
Phip
Thanks man, I made a song, and posted it, its a bit of a rough draft type thing though.
WTF guys,
Look the admin has taken his time to develop this site and the community has rallied to him but it's still his site, it's his blood and sweat in the code it's his site.
There is no charge to come and participate or use to tools, yet Im sure admin has taken his own time to create it with out being paid not to mention the server cost.
I work for a large hosting company and we charge right around $500 a month for a dedicated server, I know you can get them cheaper, but still someone is paying for that cost and I know it's not me!
I would say if you think you can do better? Bye bye, but I'll be right here.
He may be paying, but the public that uses the site still should NOT be censored. Its their right as an American citizen, for Nightmare [Lebanon] and I think Bodom [Canada] make up your own rights! lol jk.
so with your logic, it would be ok for me to come to your house where you pay rent and keep your stuff, and i could say what ever i want you and you have no rights to stop me.
Look you spoiled little brats, need to learn some respect for the work of others, especially with it's done is someone free time, and with our charge.
If this is the type of BS that is going to come from this site then maybe I'll leave.
@telecrater,
Don't leave, stay and fight. I think it's worth it!
Phip
maybe you should. and yeah, if someone comes to your apartment where you pay rent they have the right to say whatever you want. you have the authority to kick them out, but not silence them.
you need to learn some respect for what you take for granted. no violation of human rights should be allowed. deleting posts because it's just spam is one thing, that's not speech, just words used as annoyances. deleting someones words because you do not like what they said is disgusting; and it doesn't matter if he sacrificed his daughter and used her blood to cool his CPU while programmed the site until his fingers bled and he had carpal tunnel tomb torker syndrome; nothing can give him the moral authority to censor based on his opinions of what is and is not appropriate. nothing. that moral authority simply does not exist; unless you literally sell your life as a slave, like in the military, that right can not be abridged.
did you read his post? It was the biggest pile of gibberish I have ever read, not to mention it was a waste of the 1's and 0's and mips used to server that page.
And Baudelaire, you make a good point, if I come to your house and start yelling and screaming and being an ass, you can kick me out. how is that different than "kicking the post out". the post was deleted because it was a nuisance. Not everything is being "censored" just the stupid stuff.
Your freedom of speech only last until you star infridging on someone elses rights.
We can talk about freedom of speech until your blue in the face, the fact of the matter is that you don't always have the right to be listened to. here we are in admins house, if he chose to delete a post that is his right. saying other wise is infringing on admins right to manage his property as he sees fit.
So whats the solution, that that "song" post it on your blogger site, or my space where you have control over it. buy your own web server and start your own site.
there is no "right to not be offended" or "right to hear what you want to hear". it doesn't exist.
if he wants to delete spam, fine. that's not speech, really.
if he wants to ban people, fine. not going to do much good though.
but taking a post, that is not intended as spam, and deleting it, is crossing the line.
we don't have a right to be listened to, but we don't have to listen to something we don't want to... no one is forcing anything on anyone here.
your missing the point, this is admins house he can do what ever he wants, he pays the server rent and built this site from scratch.
You keep talking about censorship and freedom of speech but remember the other rights too. And just became you have these right don't mean you can say anything you want. There are laws protecting individuals from speech. Ever heard of slander and libel?
I do not run my house as a democracy, I don't let my kid's vote on what's for dinner or when it's bed time. other wise they would have cake for dinner and bed time would be 4 am.
In fact I vote that this post gets deleted or as Baudelaire would say "Censored" it's not helping the site over all and frankly i tire of arguing with a bull headed person as fine as you. Your charming personality and your witty since of perspective makes me what to turd, so excuse me.
so like my steamy turd can someone "fush this post down"?
"your missing the point, this is admins house he can do what ever he wants, he pays the server rent and built this site from scratch."
you can't violate someone else's right, even in your own REAL house.
"You keep talking about censorship and freedom of speech but remember the other rights too. And just became you have these right don't mean you can say anything you want. There are laws protecting individuals from speech. Ever heard of slander and libel?"
yes, you CAN say whatever you want. first of all, show me how slander and libel are in any way related to anything that the admin would delete here; second of all, slander and libel are fuzzy laws, and are enforced only as far as actual damage can be proved, and as far as the calculated nature of the words to do said damage can be proved. third of all, there is no right protecting your feelings or dainty sensibilities; freedom comes with things such as being offended and aggravated. if i so desired, i could call black people ****s; i don't choose to, but i have every right to, and if someone doesn't like it, they don't have the right to silence me, they have the right to argue why they think i should not say it. freedom has no exceptions but where you take away someone else s freedom.
"I do not run my house as a democracy, I don't let my kid's vote on what's for dinner or when it's bed time. other wise they would have cake for dinner and bed time would be 4 am."
the child is not allowed positive rights until 18. the child is, essentially, property.
"In fact I vote that this post gets deleted or as Baudelaire would say "Censored" it's not helping the site over all and frankly i tire of arguing with a bull headed person as fine as you. Your charming personality and your witty since of perspective makes me what to turd, so excuse me."
woah woah woah, not helping the site? neither is your side of the argument, neither is the thread, and yet here we are, two humans involved in discourse, and your reaction is to whine to the mod that i be censored because you don't like what i have to say, and because of my 'charming personality'. you tire of arguing with someone that both disagrees with you, and intellectually, operates from basic postulates that you can undermine, but not come out in the open and disparage. see, communists and tyrants like you are careful to avoid the image of being opposed to the existence of everything they do not personally like, and so must find other means to silence all dissent and opposition. people like me will simply stand on what you don't dare to touch, and 'take the high road', and not resort to underhanded and dastardly tactics such as yours.
people like you say you like freedom, but when you see a free person, or a person using their freedom, you get angry or scared, and you try to shut them down, close them out, block them off. you say things like 'rights are limited'. you appeal to safety and efficiency, as if those are more important then freedom. it's really depressing.
i think these posts are too long, im not reading this! =p
The topic was deleted for "bad" language. That's all.
If I make it again and I don't cuss will it still be deleted?????
telecrater wrote:so with your logic, it would be ok for me to come to your house where you pay rent and keep your stuff, and i could say what ever i want you and you have no rights to stop me. Look you spoiled little brats, need to learn some respect for the work of others, especially with it's done is someone free time, and with our charge.Yes it would be okay. And for the record, no one told him to go pay money to make this site, he did that by choice, personal decision, etc. He should know by now that NOBODY likes to be censored, let alone have their words permanently deleted because he see it "Unfit". No matter how petty or stupid it is, nobody should be silenced, it is your choice if you want to read it or not, AND you can call me a dip*** for posting it, but to totally wipe it out is un-needed.
"The topic was deleted for "bad" language. That's all."
you know where else "bad" language is censored? china and russia.
it's not anyones job to decide for another man if their language, words and though are bad.
its his site for crying out loud, he can censor what he wants to.