This is a read-only archive of the All Guitar Chords forum, 2005–2017. Posting is closed.
What is happening to good music?
gx1327 · 2010-04-26 10:21
JoshJones wrote:Good music will never die, most of you aren't old enough to go to jazz/piano/dive bars or aren't in college yet. Once you get to that point all sorts of talent will show itself
i second that! i can't tell you how many CDs i posess from unknown bands because i see them play at a dive bar and get into them and walk out the door. of course, most of the time i buy a CD it's because i've imbibed an incredile amount of beer and the music isn't as good as i remembered (or didn't remember) it being the night before!
also i was never really into "guitar rock". you know, i like rock music, and i enjoy hendrix, but i never listened to him at home. SRV, and other guitar greats... i never really paid attention... UNTIL i see cover bands play them well. and they rock it out. i live in a neighborhood with a lot of blues/jazz bars walking distance from my apartment. there is a bar called 1860s that has blues and jazz music 7 nights a week. that's how i got into a lot of this stuff now at a later point in life.
Domigan_Lefty wrote:Punk today is just f*gs with a guitar and mic whining
---
What happened to bands like Van Halen, Jimi Hendrix, old school Green Day/Blink 182/Metallica, Papa Roach?
that's kind of funny to me that you whine about "punk music" and then proclaim that blink and papa roach are somehow good bands? i don't dislike blink-182, but they aren't a punk band. they are the closest thing to a punk band in recent years, but nowhere close to what i consider punk. true punk music has been hiding in the shadows for the last few years. the last good punk album i can think of off the top of my head is the distllers' "coral fang" which came out in...2000-2003? i think?
punk has more to do with attitude than musical style. blink uses a lot of power chords, fast hooks, and upbeat tempos but the music is too happy. both in lyrical content and the feeling it gives.
i also think it's funny that you guys are focusing on mainstream music. mainstream music is always inferior to the "good stuff" that is under the surface. yeah, justin bieber and lady gaga kind of suck. so don't go to their concerts. don't listen to the top-40 station. turn on XM-21 "alt. nation", go to a yeah yeah yeahs show, read alternative music publications (i like pitchfork).
if you only listen to mainstream music, you're only going to experience mainstream music...
JoshJones · 2010-04-26 11:41
gx is right, I've seen so many awesome covers of songs where a no-name band rocks the song then I go home and find out who actually performed it.
Great example was when i saw the Raconteurs play Rich Kid Blues, I had no idea that was a Terry Reid song, that led me to all sorts of stuff that he's done.
Pitchfork is awesome for many of the great modern bands, Flaming Lips, Radiohead, Wilco, My Morning Jacket, Band of Horses, Modest Mouse, they may not have a "guitar rock" sound but they still are awesome live (I can vouch for all these bands at least)
*edit* Another time I was in Asheville and got some free tickets to see The Secret Machines (great live band) and Kings of Leon (right after their first album). They had an opener, The Helio Sequence. They were this electronic-pop-rock group that did everything with 2 guys, it was amazing. Needless to say, I bought their album and a poster.
gx1327 · 2010-04-26 12:21
well although i respect and occasionally enjoy real "guitar rock" songs and bands, it's not my preferred music. a lot of the songs i listen to have a guitar part but it is not the main part. like for instance, hot chip. very much an electronic band (four guys with keyboards/drum machines and one with a guitar). but i like the guitar parts in their music. it's just simple rhythms and solos. nothing mind shattering like a hendrix jam.
so yeah i agree that the pitchfork scene isn't mostly "guitar rock" but the reason i read it (the news, not the reviews) is becasue the music as a whole is really good, and most of it is not mainstream.
for instance, i consider kings of leon a "poor man's" band of horses. band of horses is the same style of music, kind of a blue collar soaring power rock, as kings of leon, but i think horses do it so much better. and yet, very few people know who band of horses are.
JazzMaverick · 2010-07-04 18:25
I'm bringing this one back again 'cause I made a loser facebook page about it :D
I would like you guys to join so noobs can hear real musicians discuss the matter :D
Music Is On The Verge Of Dying (http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=134493229905080&ref=mf)
EMB5490 · 2010-07-04 19:28
i dont have a facebook anymore but i logged onto my friends to see it and that picture is beautful. did you draw it? hate to take the conversation from music...
i think the worst is the quality of lyrics and new beats. beautiful music made by artists like elton john, john lennon, george harrison, james taylor, csn etc etc etc seems to be gone, and their "soft rock" seems to have transfered to bands like...? 5 for fighting may be one. its still good but its not fantastic you know, i feel like its changed but the similar styles and comparisons seem to be getting worse in my opinion,
i really cant compare pop nowadays because its all mtv crap and thats just not fair
but soft rock now vs soft rock then (idk bands now but before i mentioned b4)
hard rock vs hard rock then (i mean bands like the answer now compared to led zep, not like kings of leon)
rock now (kings of leon...i guess?) vs rock then (pink floyd, skynyrd)
even underground music is worse you know
like galactic which is a funky band now cant compare to bands like the meters or funkadelic...
bands like phish compared to the grateful dead. im not saying music now is terrible ( i LOVE phish, string cheese etc) but i feel like its getting worse, the comparable bands from now to then, seem to be worse, i dont just mean mainstream mtv crap. i think the reason there was less of that then was because of no mtv, no disney, no big corps training kids to sell out as fast and as much as they possibly can before they go away (hannah montana in 10 years... psh ill see her at a 7/11.) so i dont think its fair to compare pop now to then.
one could also argue that its very opinionated and that for some is the best music...(i guess some people really like screaming death metal the best?)
but in musically speaking i cant fathom how anyone can say that screaming **** or anything else now is better musically speaking then, then. i mean sure that death stuff is incredibly hard to play (once you take a week or 2 to learn sweeping and get it solid and having tons of gain to chuggg) but musically speaking i dont think anything now compares:
im gona need phip for this one but phip take the most (or one of) the top songs now (thats not disney, no hannah montana, i assume the top will be lady gaga because thats all i hear now) and take a top song say 35 or 40 years ago and compare them.
lets say even radiohead which ive heard is the pink floyd of today, firstly i dont know how anyone can say that, compare anything by pink floyd to anything by radiohead, musically pink floyd blows them away. shine on you crazy diamond, echoes, great gig in the sky, all their albums are fantastic...
i also compare lady gaga and her techno pop to disco, a passing fad, awesome to poorly dance to but a passing fad that wont too much be remembered by anyone in 10 years except those who loved it...
JazzMaverick · 2010-07-05 21:46
People want to be like the greats (which is fine) but they lose their originality because of it... they're trying so hard to be like someone else that music isn't new anymore.
Then again, there are plenty of musicians who get away from this (people like Andy McKee)
The music I make I try to make it as original as possible, I obviously have inspiration and that is going to be heard in my playing but I also have a strong desire to play nothing but my own stuff without the help of others - just like they did. Why does that desire need to fade just because there's soooo much music now?
macandkanga · 2010-07-05 23:02
I don't think music today is bad, in fact, there's a lotta great music out there. It's what we're exposed to on the radio and tv that's bad. Marketting a pop star or band nowadays is a lot more refined to hit targeted paying audiences more now than ever. Bands of yesteryear like Led Zeppelin, Yes or Genesis for example would be successful in today's market, but they wouldn't be nearly the powerhouses that they were in the 60s and 70s. Conversely, the Jonas Bros or the like wouldn't have made it at all back then.
The great thing about today is the Internet. There is a plethora of music for your perusal at your finger tips! You can listen and NOT buy! You can buy a whole cd or just one song just sitting on your couch. I didn't have that choice when I was a kid. Also, albums and high fidelity equipment were a lot more expensive in those days.
I also think we are so spoiled today with all that we have, especially in the area of technology, that it makes it a lot easier to complain about what's bad instead of sharing with each the things that are good.
Well, that's my two cents!
nullnaught · 2010-07-06 22:13
JazzMaveric says it best. That all art is niether good nor bad. Humans make that judgement.
EMB5490 · 2010-07-06 22:18
Yep except modern art! one day stuck my spoon in a really frozen ice-cream box thingy and the spoon bent...two days later it was in a modern art museum :)
Ozzfan486 · 2010-07-06 22:25
I think it's just that it's new. I've been conjuring this thought for a while now. I'll take for example the Black Rain album form Ozzy. It came out in '07 and at the time it was "eh" to me. Now, three years later, I love it. What I'm saying is that music ages like wine, and only gets better. Like, way back when you probably had the kids who liked Black Sabbath and called all the Led Zep fans puss!es. It's the same way we have people listening to Slipknot calling those who listen Muse or something names. It's always the same attitude, and I think that in 20 years, some of today's bands will be looked at in the same way we look at Zeppelin, Sabbath, Guns N' Roses, Nirvana, etc.
Ozz
Jemba · 2010-07-07 11:00
Buckethead is one of (probably the) finest musicians on the planet. He can shred like a robot, and show more emotion than Soul. He can play just about EVERYTHING there is to play on the guitar. He probably wears a Bucket and a Mask to continue his peaceful life, without the press on him. He is brilliant.
EMB5490 · 2010-07-07 12:37
Jemba wrote:Buckethead is one of (probably the) finest musicians on the planet. He can shred like a robot, and show more emotion than Soul. He can play just about EVERYTHING there is to play on the guitar. He probably wears a Bucket and a Mask to continue his peaceful life, without the press on him. He is brilliant.
dont know how that contributes to whats happening with good music... also disagree with you there.
btimm · 2010-07-07 12:50
It's simple really. The more commercial music now is lacking quality relative to times past. But that doesn't mean that the music nowdays in general is lacking, that is just flat out false. Broaden your horizons and you will find loads of good music. Check out bands that aren't main stream. JustJeff posted a video of a band called The Reign of Kindo a while back. I gave them a listen and then went and bought both of their albums, because they are very good. Killswitch Engage is a very good band as well. Going in other directions, I started listening to some Infected Mushroom, which is not normally my cup of tea, but I heard a cover AlexB did and was blown away. And of course, check out Minus the Bear. They are amazing musicians that put forth great music and continue to branch in new directions with each album. I told gx to check them out, now he loves them. You just gotta open up your ears, be open to different types of music, and then you can appreciate the quality music that is being made these days.
I don’t think anything, philosophically speaking, is bad or good. It either is or it isn’t. Bad or good is just a way of communicating to others our opinion about something. Popularity and sales are two of the things that are pushed on us by major media types that encourage large groups of us think something is good and even sometimes bad. They just want us to look or listen and ultimately buy!
So, in my opinion, Paris Hilton is a bad musician (I tried to think of the most extreme example to make my point). Yes, she actually recorded a CD. It is absolutely horrible, again, in my opinion. However, on Amazon her CD gets 3 out of 5 stars! That’s not bad! If you actually listen to it there are some catchy songs and it’s produced well. But, who is Paris Hilton? What has she really done to contribute to music all on her own? This CD is obliviously produced all around her but with Paris as the center marketing piece. Kids see her popularity and success and want to be like her and validate their own existence by buying this CD.
Don’t get me wrong. It’s not like this is new. This sort of thing has been happening since the beginning of the commercialization of music. Records were first produced in the 40’s and 50’s and companies saw the value of producing an act and marketing it to its fullest potential. It’s just getting worse with every new decade.
Now if your opinion is that Paris Hilton, and all that she represents, is a good musician that makes good quality heartfelt original music then God Bless ya! I write a lot about this because as a musician that puts a lot of effort into learning and producing my own music I think it is important to distinguish between what deserves good credit where credit is due and what doesn’t. I want my kids and all young people to understand this. For the most part I think most of the young people that belong to this forum do.
Jemba · 2010-07-07 14:03
EMB5490 wrote:dont know how that contributes to whats happening with good music... also disagree with you there.
Sorry, I was just replying to TheAmericanBrit and Baudelaire's argument at the top ;D
Guitarslinger124 · 2010-07-07 14:30
This is an age old argument which will forever answer itself. Too bad most people don't see it that way.
Take a second and really think what you guys are discussing. I think the very fact that you are even talking about this proves that there is a certain, undeniable quality in today's music. If the music is causing so many thought provoking arguments and discussions, then it is doing exactly what any good music does to your brain. It makes you think and you can't stop, even if you try.
Here is my post from Jazz's Facebook group:
Personal opinion: Music is not even close to dying. Commercial industry has made it extremely easy for any musician, practically anwhere, to write, record, produce and sell their own music. I am going to go out on a limb and say that compared to the "classic days", the industry today is a monster incapable of defeat.
The sheer number of different genres introduced by today's artists trumps any other era by a long shot. There is a genre and musician for anything and everything a person could possibly desire, within realistic standards. People today have become much more experimental with music and sound. Isn't that what music is about? Freedom of expression?
"One mans trash is another mans treasure". I think that phrase is appropriate for today's music as well. If all music were an accurate expression of someone's soul, then there would be no bad music. The only "bad" music today is music written not from the heart or from the brain, but rather from the deep pockets of a multi-billionare.
Music has no limits. Every sound from your own footsteps to birds chirping to the wind the rustling dead leaves, qualifies as music.
-"An art of sound in time that expresses ideas and emotions in significant forms through the elements of rhythm, melody, harmony, and color."
-"The tones or sounds employed, occurring in single line (melody) or multiple lines (harmony), and sounded or to be sounded by one or more voices or instruments, or both."
In short, music today is perhaps "better" than it ever was. With all the diversity and willing participants, the world of music has never been so vibrant and powerful.
macandkanga wrote:I don’t think anything, philosophically speaking, is bad or good.
This, for the most part, is very true.
Honestly, I don't see a problem with anyone's music. I think the problem is that a lot of people (not just "today's kids", but the music listening population as a whole) are ignorant (in the most respectful sense of the word) and naive. If one were to respect any bit of music for exactly what it is, an expressive component of someones mind, there would be less bias against any particular genre or era of music.
A friend of mine once quoted, "There are only two types of music, good music and bad music". I suppose on an extremely personal level, this is can be true. If music moves you, you consider it good, if not, then it must be bad. However, keeping selfishness aside, music is not solely for you the individual listener. That, I think, is something that most people cannot understand. Thus comes, the purpose of an opinion. So individual people can impart their feelings on others about how they feel, as individuals. But music is not for one person.
I just got interrupted and lost my train of thought. I might post again when I get it back. Until then...
«Rock on!»
macandkanga · 2010-07-07 14:44
Guitarslinger124 wrote:If all music were an accurate expression of someone's soul, then there would be no bad music. The only "bad" music today is music written not from the heart or from the brain, but rather from the deep pockets of a multi-billionare.
So then you agree with me? Because that's my whole point and it's getting worse. Where this is most apparent, at least for me, is the radio. I listened almost exclusively to the radio when I was a kid. The music I heard was NEW music by Yes, Genesis, Led Zeppelin, Kiss, Judas Priest, George Benson, Black Sabbath, Kansas, Tom Petty, Fleetwood Mac, Ohio Players, Earth Wind and Fire, on and on and on. I don’t hear anything close to this on the radio today. If I do, it’s on classic radio stations that play the bands I just mentioned.
Again, as I mentioned before, I do have the internet and Sirius Radio where I can hear a lot of cool new stuff but not like it was. Yes, you youngans will be saying this too in 20 to 30 years and you will be right!
Guitarslinger124 · 2010-07-07 14:45
Yes, I do. I think your previous post was well stated truth.
«Rock on!»
Jemba · 2010-07-07 14:55
The thing is, you ask a band (rock, metal, jazz and others) why they like being a band, they say "I love the touring and our amazing fans" and other things like that, and then you ask the multi-millionaires like Britney Spears and the will say "................... (How much do I get paid for miming at concerts again?)." They just care about their money, their clothes, the fame and "how many magazines am I in this week?"
reckzilla · 2010-11-30 16:53
My friends music is going to ***. I'm 18 so I was around for some of the good stuff, but now it's dying. Very few band are any good anymore. But I have a proposal how about instead of complaining we go pick up are ***ing guitars, grab are awesome friends and put together bands. We need to run this Beiber, and Jonas crap out of existence. We here know what needs to be done lets start a revolution and bring rock and metal back to it's former glory. Iron Maiden, Joe Satriani, Metallica, Megadeth, Eddie Van Halen, Sammy Hagar, and many other bands are still out there doin their thing. We just recently lost Dio but lets join the remaining bands and return music to its former glory!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
neomass1 · 2010-12-03 15:31
I feel that every generation has felt this at one time or another. Its sad to see a great band that you love and feel fall to the way side, But all good things come to in end. Hate saying that but its true. I miss my 90's, but there is still hope. Keeping my eyes open I have seen the glimmers of light in the darkness. People who have passion like us will fallow their dreams (I hope). Everyday there are bands inspired by Nirvana, Jimmie, and every band you love. I say let main stream flow where they want, what goes around comes around. I hope my kids grow up then so they get a taste of my life and moments. Let us all stand for our passions, turn up the volume so the world know what we like. Keep the music you love alive.
God Bless Peace and Love.
AlexB · 2010-12-03 15:36
Good music is everywhere,even mainstream,but there are not many good listeners