All Guitar Chords · Forum archive

What is happening to good music?

blackholesun · 2008-08-31 14:54

JazzMaverick wrote:There will always be people who don't like certain styles of music
I said nothing about disliking rap. I like a bit of rap and hip hop, and I've stated that many times on this forum in similar threads. And whether I like that album or genre or not, that album still has BAD reviews from both music journalists and general music fans. Therefore, it's bad music.

RelaxedDude · 2008-08-31 15:19

So, with that in mind, are there any bands out there that you guys think we should keep our eyes on?

league · 2008-08-31 16:31

Damn these posts are long! And mine will be too. I agree with what gustavo said about hip-hop. But hey everyone has to remember that Metal and Real Rock or Classic Rock was mainstream in the past few decades. Then there are the hugely succesful mainstream artists that fall into the Pop category. I agree that there are a lot of crappy musical acts out there but Notim can probably agree that they were rampant through the 80s too. BTW Listen to KLOS Classic Rock 95.5 Los Angeles it ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Crunch · 2008-08-31 16:35

KUQQ 102.1 Twin Lakes-Okoboji... yeah, I live in Iowa :( Okoboji is pretty cool, though.

baudelaire · 2008-08-31 19:23

"that album still has BAD reviews from both music journalists and general music fans. Therefore, it's bad music." neither music journalists nor music fans have been declared by the muse the sole arbiter of artistic worth. i think the album sucks. you think the album sucks. but if we were to meet a person who happened to like it, there is no legitimate argument in our favor. because music is subjective. you can use whatever adjectives you want to describe it; your opinion can be whatever you want it to be; but it holds no authority anywhere outside your own mind.

Crunch · 2008-08-31 19:57

In theory, baudelaire, you're correct. However, anywhere outside the discussion of metacognition, and many other words with "meta" as a prefix, that argument doesn't really hold water. Sure, music, along with any art, is subjective, but that doesn't mean anything that comes from an instrument or someone's mouth is good music (or, in this case, music at all). In general, art is usually held to be worth what thought it is expressing, combined with how well it expresses that thought. Sometimes, as with many of the "bad" "artists" who have been the topics of discussion here, a piece of "art" isn't really expressing anything, but is just a brash exercise in commercialism. When this happens, I don't believe it's fair to call the product good art/music, or for that matter, art/music at all. P.S. I used two sets of quotation marks, '"bad" "artists,"' in an effort to keep the words from being used, in this particular instance, as they had been earlier in the thread. Well, not actually used, but referred to. I hope that makes sense. Adieu.

baudelaire · 2008-08-31 22:23

oh, i understand the grim reality that is terrible art. i know that art is less subjective then it can be earnestly proven to be. we all know the whiny queer music teens listen to is of no artistic merit. i just think people were going to far and being too liberal with the idea that 'good music' is not being made; so i become the devils advocate to equalize the situation. also, the connection to commercial aspects exists, but is far vaguer then you might assume. a piece of art ought be judged by no index but it's quality... don't think that art made for money is somehow degraded. you'd be surprised at how many things many of the great composers did to make some cash... the difference between the good and the bad ones is that the bad ones made bad music for cash, and the good ones made good music for cash. there are a great deal of very good and talented artists that do what they do because they love their art, of course - there are easier ways to make money - but they certainly do it for money as well.

Empirism · 2008-09-01 16:14

True. But we must remember that those artists actually do not get the most money. Recording companies get the most money, what artists get when their recording companies are drained them dry is fame, Oh yeah the fame, what an splendid source of inspiration and reason to make music. the art?. For me "artists" like Britney Spears and alike are form of commercial entertainment to massess, not art, not music. Just an plastic surgered puppets full of silicon to entertain those who even not want anything but jump up and down in those Disco clubs and devour Xtacy pills. just my 2 cents

RelaxedDude · 2008-09-01 18:43

All of this is true, exept for the plain fact: Artists noadays cant compare to the artists of a few decades ago So would you say that someone is going to come about and supply us with some much needed music, or are we going to have to adapt knowing that there will never be music like the artists of time gone by?

baudelaire · 2008-09-01 19:36

relaxed dude, that's just plain damned dumb. there are as many good artists today as there were 10, 100, and 500 years ago. you're just too lazy to look for them.

joe · 2008-09-01 20:09

even baudelaire cant argue this is music :P jokes http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendid=204400412# seriously tho, he has a point. music is subjective and it is all down to personal opinion at the end of the day.

league · 2008-09-02 18:20

What Baudelaire said is also true for Bad Music. I explained it in my previous post. That being said what could be causing this sudden discontent with todays music? I'm not going to compare bands and genres because that got some people discontent in the forums.

Crunch · 2008-09-02 21:31

Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CdIQJT1dq0I I was listening to these guys earlier and thought all of you might like to hear them. They're a French Techno/Rock/Pop band called the Prototypes. Not what I would normally listen to, but I love them.

Empirism · 2008-09-03 17:01

oh my god... oh my god... ill need a whiskey... a double. I dont know what to say of that vid... when you have an feeling that cant described the feeling because lack of consepts... well, I didnt like it xD

Crunch · 2008-09-03 20:04

That's too bad emp. I was hoping someone else would like them :(

TheAmericanBrit · 2008-09-03 20:33

Miley Cyrus and The Jonas Brothers are what's killing music today (along with most rap). I can't even listen to today's music because it sucks so bad. What's worse is the fanboys/girls who think people like Cyrus and the Jonas' are actually talented. Then, they go and say The Beatles suck. It's a shame, really.

foogered · 2008-09-03 22:25

Crunch, here's a french artist that a friend of mine really digs. Her name is Yelle, and even though I'm not too big into that kind of music, I can move to it and the songs are kind of catchy. Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tmLjZrH0VlY She once told me what she was singing, but I've since forgotten.

baudelaire · 2008-09-03 23:19

well, dre's kid offed himself, so i'm not expecting any good rap out of him anytime soon. (and dr dre's kid said...) but eminem is coming out with a new album sometime soon, so rap is soon going to be infused by a GOOD album, not this shit they play on the radio. i think i heard DMX might be doing something, but i'm not sure. good music will ALWAYS exist. but, you're always going to have to LOOK for the good music of the present day... the good music of the past is already canonized for us. the, "good music is gone" deal is a illusion.

TheAmericanBrit · 2008-09-03 23:49

There will always be good music around. However, the BEST music is long gone.

baudelaire · 2008-09-04 00:16

what would make you think THAT?

CTown · 2008-09-04 00:17

Really? I thought Eminem was done. Has he decided to be the next Too Short? TI is #1 on the Billboard charts. Think it is worth the listen?

baudelaire · 2008-09-04 00:39

i dunno. i haven't heard much from him that wasn't cool. it's called, "king mathers".

TheAmericanBrit · 2008-09-04 00:56

What would make me think that? The Beatles are gone, Nirvana is no more, The Kinks are history, and B.B King should be dead any day now.

baudelaire · 2008-09-04 01:40

BB king is dead. i'm sorry, skold. and, see, thats opinion. i for one, hate nirvana, and only respect the beatles. i don't like BB kings work especially much either. i really like the kinks, but they aren't the BEST music in my opinion. actually, in my mind, we are currently in the heyday of the finest musician of the 20/21st century - buckethead. he is in my mind comparable only to the great composers of the classical and romantic era.

TheAmericanBrit · 2008-09-04 01:47

haha, buckethead is just a gimmick. Yeah, he can play fast.......and? Yeah, The Kinks may not be the best, but they are certainly better than most everything out now. Just accept the fact that the only music that is alive and thriving is crap.

keniemn · 2008-09-04 07:56

what is happening to good music? people listen to it, if they thinck its not any good they dont listen

baudelaire · 2008-09-04 11:40

buckethead? a gimmick? is that why DISNEY hires him to compose orchestrations, over all the well respected university dean of music composers, why composers have said he was the only person that truly understand schoenbergs dodecatonic matrix? not only is he indeed the most technically talented guitarist, he can play slowly better then anyone as well, he has more musical knowledge then possibly anyone on earth has EVER had, is more prolific in his work, is more unique, he has no desire to make a great deal of money from his talents - he doesn't even want recognition. he plays in little tiny gigs for peanuts, and yet axl rose could have made him a arena hitter when he recruited him for velvet revolver or whatever it was. he releases whatever he feels like, knowing that the sales will be meager.

JazzMaverick · 2008-09-04 13:23

The music that's alive now it still just as good, you know. It depends on where and what genres you’re looking at. Also as Baudelaire and I have already said, along with some other members - it's totally down to opinion. Music these days is still amazing, of course there are styles that are disliked... but have you not realised that in this day and age there is so much versatility? Compared to Mozart’s day and age when all there was, was pretty much Classical. We're blessed with so many different styles, and so many different ideas to learn from! To be honest, we should all be grateful. Even if you consider some things crap, they have melody and you can learn from that melody if you (meaning everyone) would just open your mind and listen.

TheAmericanBrit · 2008-09-04 14:32

Without his bucket, people really wouldn't care about him.

jcb3000 · 2008-09-04 14:53

did mr bucket tell you that personally? also there will always be someone in the world better than him, than anyone infact, just dont know of them...yet.

baudelaire · 2008-09-04 15:29

people certainly would care about him even without the character he created as an outlet for his art. his bucket HINDERS his career. if he lost the bucket, and simplified his music, he could DOUBLE his fan base in a few weeks. he could become a rich, famous rock star with the snap of his fingers. but he doesn't want that; he makes beautiful music, bizarre complicated music, strange music, wonderful music, and that's all he cares about. if it wasn't for his bucket and persona, he could be very wealthy, and very famous.

TheAmericanBrit · 2008-09-04 16:45

He's already famous.

baudelaire · 2008-09-04 16:49

not really. once guitar hero dies and another fad takes it's place, the people that only know about him because of jordan will forget him. he doesn't do big shows. he sells very small amounts of record. if he wanted to, he could do anything. all he'd have to do is change the way he looks and acts, and make simple music for the masses, and he could conquer the charts, make platinum albums, and have millions of fans and girls begging to fuck his brains out. he's rather handsome and jacked, which makes his character and mask and clothing even better.

TheAmericanBrit · 2008-09-04 16:50

So? He may not be at the top of the charts, but he is famous. No, he's not as well known as some, but still.

baudelaire · 2008-09-04 18:23

well, just because he dresses and acts insane, and can play faster then anyone on earth, doesn't mean he's a gimmick... you probably haven't heard much of his music. he's considered by respectable, knowledgeable people to be a extraordinary musician... in 50 years, he will most likely be considered the combination of the best of lizst and bach.

BodomBeachTerror · 2008-09-04 18:24

hes not the fastest anyway =p

TheAmericanBrit · 2008-09-04 18:25

I don't LIKE his music. I respect his ability, I just don't like his music. In the words of James Hetfield, "That's just not what music was to me".

Crunch · 2008-09-04 22:57

TheAmericanBrit wrote:Just accept the fact that the only music that is alive and thriving is crap.
I don't know if I'd say that's true. The Red Hot Chili Peppers are still a HUGE act and I think they're very talented and care about what they're doing to be called "true" musicians. Radiohead isn't quite as big, but they're still very popular. Beck too, along the same lines as Radiohead. This reminds me of a cool little lyric in Weezer's new single: "Everyone likes to dance to a happy song with a catchy chorus and beat so they can sing along Timbaland knows the way to reach the top of the charts maybe if i work with him i can perfect the art." I was kind of shocked at how similar that was to how I, personally, feel. P.S. Thanks for the song, foogered. I don't think I like it as much as the Prototypes, but I really like to hear people singing in French :)

TheAmericanBrit · 2008-09-04 23:00

Maybe if I weren't force-fed all of this Disney pop crap, I could see things the way you do.

baudelaire · 2008-09-04 23:33

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uKUYSl8c-90&feature=related do you like that?

TheAmericanBrit · 2008-09-04 23:42

The song is fine. I'm just not that into it.

Pager · 2008-09-05 08:45

dayum, i started a post on this like 3 months ago... :(

JazzMaverick · 2008-09-05 10:36

Kind of grew tired of typing my opinion on this topic when it became obvious that most of the people won't think on what's been said enough. But everyone's entitled to their own opinions.

LedZeppRox13 · 2010-04-23 18:03

i think that in like 2020 music is gonna be like all techno and computerized, and the jonas brothers and like justin bieber will be lost with all the crappy rap and stuff that doesnt even have a tune, and no one will really know who they are. but bands like Led Zeppelin<3, The Beatles, Pink Floyd, MJ, and Marvin **, like true LEGENDS of music who have inspired so many musicians will still be known of and never forgotten. I dont think Justin Bieber will inspire any great bands, it just wont happen. haha.

JoshJones · 2010-04-23 18:36

@LedZeppRox13, People say that with every generation. Think of the 70's a lot of mainstream was disco, music is music and that is what is so amazing about it. In all honesty who cares if the Jonas Brothers, and Miley rule the charts? I'll happily put on my Buddy Guy, Lightnin Hopkins, Little Walter, Peter Green, name it. Everyone here has their flavor and thats what makes music awesome. I had thought the blues was dying, than I found out about Joe Bonamassa, he's blown my mind the past few weeks. Good music will never die, most of you aren't old enough to go to jazz/piano/dive bars or aren't in college yet. Once you get to that point all sorts of talent will show itself

michaelcollins · 2010-04-23 19:38

I dont think time has anything to do with the quality of music theres always going to be great bands that blow you mind and give you goosebumps you just gotta search,and theres always gonna be lame crap out there and you cant stop it,you just have to let the lame **s live in that world and understand that real music never went away or got worse,but is getting better everyday

Domigan_Lefty · 2010-04-24 07:54

as time passes, music seems to be getting worse. I cannot turn on a radio without hearing bulls*it (lady gaga, justin beber, rap, hiphop, extremehardcoredeathcoremetal, dragonforce, and more) Punk today is just f*gs with a guitar and mic whining Metal today is overly distorted guitar with no real vocals (most of the time) Pop today is a collection of people with only one song youl ever hear from them What happened to bands like Van Halen, Jimi Hendrix, old school Green Day/Blink 182/Metallica, Papa Roach?

JazzMaverick · 2010-04-24 14:48

Wow, that was a VERY ignorant comment. You may not like it - but others do - and they like it for a reason. It doesn't have to be what you consider good - THEY actually made it, while you're sitting on your computer complaining about them. If you look deep enough into every genre, there is always good music. ALWAYS.

BodomBeachTerror · 2010-04-24 15:12

JazzMaverick wrote:If you look deep enough into every genre, there is always good music. ALWAYS.
even if you absolutely hate it

Empirism · 2010-04-24 15:18

To make things bit more ignorant, I might add that we came to the conclusion that we cannot choose what is good music and what's not, because different tastes of inviduals... So it seem's that music is not getting worse, but audiences are getting worse, they listen "crap music", more those "crap taste" inviduals are, they buy more "crap music" and thats how the music business big boys are smiling wide... (how I know their taste is crap and mine not... Ofcourse my opinion is right, because... well its anyway right... ...) Allright, seriously... music is not just music today, its entertainment, its IDOLS, its CHARACTERISTICS, its FASHION. Things like lady gaga forexample, what is it? music, yeah a bit... (there are somekind of rhythm there, there are some melody... crap or not, that is...) but more than that, what it is? Yeah, its sex dancing on the line of good taste... How it be so popular then, well lol... we know the answer, our minds are dirty. If we look top10's how many sex oriented stuff you see there?... but anyway, mankind are survived for much serious issues than these, so lets just see where things are goin, maybe someone blows the fashions to next reality. You never know. just my...2 c...(actually my boring time with my boring screen...) Empirism