JustJeff wrote:Every CEO can be a grunt workerWRONG I'd like to see a CEO get off his ass and get out from behind his desk to move 60 lbs bags of cement all day. I really would. Because the majority of these CEOs would either 1. think they're too good for work like that OR 2. do not possess that amount of physical strength and stamina.
Hmmmm...
DarkRiff wrote:I'd like to see a CEO get off his ass and get out from behind his desk to move 60 lbs bags of cement all day. I really would. Because the majority of these CEOs would either 1. think they're too good for work like that OR 2. do not possess that amount of physical strength and stamina.Just because they WON'T do it doesn't mean they can't do it. And to assume that any given CEO doesn't possess the physical strength and stamina to do grunt work has literally no merit behind it whatsoever.
@Jeff Think of it this way.
The workforce is a computer.The intelligent
skilled,schooled person is the hard drive.The
uskilled grunt worker is the solder(or pwr cable)
Now think,that hard drive is useless without those miniscule
pieces of solder(or pwr cable).Now if something were to go wrong with
the solder(or pwr cable)It could be easily replaced for a small
price,but the fact is the Hard drive NEEDS
the solder(pwr cable) To be able.to function properly.So even
though the solder is plentiful and cheap,and does a simple job
It is still just as important as the hard drive,so it should be treated with better respect.
btimm wrote:And to assume that any given CEO doesn't possess the physical strength and stamina to do grunt work has literally no merit behind it whatsoever.Ok Let's see Trump do it. Go look at the some of the big name CEOs out there and you tell me if their out of shape bodies could do some bull work.
Most Ceo's work all day in climate controlled areas,and sit
behind a desk. There farthest they walk is to the snack machine.
They even have people make and bring them coffee and food.
Unless the manual labor is lifing a fork.or counting
money,I honestly dont think a person that hails from an office
enviroment could do that sort of work.
Its like throwing a penguin in the sahara,there not
adapted to that enviroment.
@Gshredder
You keep going to the "importance" of the whole picture, but I've already said, importance is not the factor here. At the end of the day, if a harddrive fails, you're looking at losing the ENTIRE computer, because that's the brains of the entire system. If the solder fails, you go out to radioshack/homedepot/loews and get some solder and sit down and fix it. Nothing serious has been lost.
Here's the point I'm trying to make and that's it:
The skills required to do your average "blue-collar" working job are not hard to acquire. The skills required to be a CEO or "higher-up" are much harder to acquire.
In general, you and I could not run a franchise or do what Trump does. However, most of us could flip burgers or clean hotel rooms.
gshredder2112 wrote:Most Ceo's work all day in climate controlled areas,and sit behind a desk. There farthest they walk is to the snack machine. They even have people make and bring them coffee and food. Unless the manual labor is lifing a fork.or counting money,I honestly dont think a person that hails from an office enviroment could do that sort of work. Its like throwing a penguin in the sahara,there not adapted to that enviroment.I work in an office environment and sit behind a computer and don't walk further than 3 blocks or so to get to the atrium where several coworkers and I eat our lunches. I also lift weights 3 times a week (thinking maybe upping it to 6, not sure), play 2+ hours of full court basketball and hustle while playing, and also play tennis for 2-3 hours once or twice a week. I can easily do the job you describe and I work in an office environment. Jeff is in an office environment while working on his PhD. I don't know about his exercise routine if he has one, but I would bet while taking dog odds that he can easily do grunt work. The type of assumption you are making is simply incorrect.
DarkRiff wrote:Ok Let's see Trump do it. Go look at the some of the big name CEOs out there and you tell me if their out of shape bodies could do some bull work.Physical abilities can be acquired - having the intellect to be a CEO may not be something that can be acquired, even with persistent studies. As Jeff said, I doubt I could be a CEO of a Fortune 500 company, but I know I can do the grunt work of any factory job and I know that 99% of factory workers cannot do my job. Supple + demand.
@Btimm Your not A Ceo.Plus,thats you btimm,not every other
person who sits behind a desk.
@jeff I wont deny that. But as long as someone is working
regardless of skills they should be payed a decent wage to survive on.
gshredder2112 wrote:@Btimm Your not A Ceo.Plus,thats you btimm,not every other person who sits behind a desk.No, I am not a CEO, but this is how the vast majority of people I work with treat their bodies. The notion that people who work at desks all the time are out of shape is just not true anymore. And I know for a fact that many of the people who hold upper management positions in my company work out on a regular basis - it's just too important these days not to do so.
I think CEO's should work out more and brush their teeth for a full two minutes with a really soft brush. Then they would be nicer to poor people.
Many people can lift 60lbs bags of cement all day and I bet many CEOs can do it also. However, many people can't be CEOs. The CEO of my company gets here from Pasadena everyday at 6:30am and worksout in the gym here. I usually see him when I'm getting here at 8:00am. He sometimes leaves after I do. He also drives a 2005 Prius. We're a company of about 400 people. I'm sure he makes 10 to 20 times what I make but he earns it.
He is responsible for managing this whole operation and has to ensure that we are profitable and growing as a company. As long as he does, he gets paid to do so. Just as a Major league player is paid to hit a round ball with a round bat and acheives whatever stats he is paid to do so, he will continue to get what he deserves.
We all like to think because we work hard all day that we should get paid more but it's just not reallity.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT...
I was once told that if you work from the neck down you could earn 50-100 grand but millionaires are made by working from the neck up.
@MoshZilla1016
Exactly. For my Ph.D program, I'm always told this:
You guys get paid to think, not to do.
Back to finances, I am glad that a few states started implementing drug tests for welfare. It's definitely a quality start. I get tested randomly for my career path, those getting aid should as well. Plus, if they need government assistance, then they obviously can't afford to waste money on drugs. This should be mandated by all 50 states.
Well if welfare is your job,then it should be treated like one.
Drug tests included.
Btimm,In your opinion,do you think alchohol and tabbacco
should be welfare disqualifiers?
@ gshredder2112: That's a really tough call, because they aren't illegal and would be very difficult to regulate. It'd be great if the people on welfare would just realize that adds to their problems by removing money they would have had to spend on something productive or to save, but this isn't a fantasy world.
Virginia will never remove tobacco. It is a huge cashcrop for our country. Marijuana could be a huge cashcrop as well. Alcohol... well that's a different story. You're talking about something that was drank more than water in our earlier years (this is because it was safer than drinking water, which was almost always contaminated). Alcohol will never be removed from our society, and as an avid drinker, I would not like to see it removed.
However, I understand the bias that comes out, since there is a ban on Marijuana and not on alcohol or tobacco. But you also have to realize is that where do you draw the line? Do you allow all drugs or do you just allow some drugs. If it's some, how do you draw the line for what's legal and what's not? Do you only regulate consumption instead of supply?
You're getting into a very complicated subject.
And on welfare. I don't care about the drug tests, but you should only be able to stay on welfare for up to 6 months. After which, you're on your own, and not allowed to reapply for another year.
@Btimm, I agree in theory but in reallity a drug user will then use some of the welfare money to buy a clean test. Therefore the state and the user are spending more of our tax dollars. Drug tests and administration of those tests are expensive.
JustJeff wrote:And on welfare. I don't care about the drug tests, but you should only be able to stay on welfare for up to 6 months. After which, you're on your own, and not allowed to reapply for another year.This is probably a better solution than drug testing.
Yeah. Basically, our government should either cut a check or not. It provides way to many regulated services that require way to much administration. That's where all the waste is.
My company's primary customers are franchise car dealers. They either buy our services or dont. We bill, they pay. However, government institutions buy our products also. When they do, they need a P.O., a bid, they insist on paying tax when we don't charge tax, or they want us to sign a 20 page agreement, on and on. Then they order things and don't pay. They are by far our worst customer.