All Guitar Chords · Forum archive

What is the key of this song? Please help!

avwb · 2011-05-19 09:16

Hi guys, I'm doing a school assigment of song analysis and recognising the key of a song is one of the tasks... I'm clueless! I tried to read the tutorials and work it out but it's just not happening. I was wondering if someone was able to tell the key by looking at its chords (chords is all I have, no tabs, no sheet music). The song has never been released so there will not be anything on the interent about it. The chords below are the first part of the song (intro, verse, chorus). I would really appreacite it, thanks in advance! D min G maj C maj D min G maj F maj d min g min c maj7 d min a# maj c maj7 d min a# maj c maj7 g maj d min g maj f maj g maj d min The song finishes with G min

gshredder2112 · 2011-05-19 11:09

I dont have time to go over this whole thing but just by looking i would say Cmin DONT take this advice,im.just throwning out my guess.

tinyskateboard · 2011-05-19 11:15

Which set (of chords) is the intro, the chours and the verse? At least give us that, eh? And welcome.

nullnaught · 2011-05-19 11:20

Id say mostly C. But it modulates.

btimm · 2011-05-19 11:58

avwb wrote:I was wondering if someone was able to tell the key by looking at its chords
I would say you should probably do your own homework. Asking for help and asking someone for the answer are two totally different beasts.

gx1327 · 2011-05-19 12:32

eh, we can give him some pointers to get on the right track... A#. think about it. how many keys have an A#? key / sharps C / none G / F# D / F#, C# A / F#, C#, G# E / F#, C#, G#, D# B / F#, C#, G#, D#, A# F#/ don't even worry about F# i hate F# BUT --- how can it be in the key of B with a C, D, and G natural? i don't know. you are the one studying music, you tell me! but i will say that up until the A# you have: Dm, G, C, and F. to me that looks like ii, V, I, and IV...

btimm · 2011-05-19 12:40

gx1327 wrote:eh, we can give him some pointers to get on the right track...
I absolutely agree with this.

BodomBeachTerror · 2011-05-19 14:20

The way my guitar teacher taught me was to find all the NOTES you are playing, and then put them in order, then walla!

avwb · 2011-05-19 16:08

tinyskateboard wrote:Which set (of chords) is the intro, the chours and the verse? At least give us that, eh? And welcome.
Intro D min G maj C maj Verse D min G maj F maj d min g min Chorus c maj7 d min a# maj c maj7 d min a# maj c maj7 g maj d min g maj f maj g maj d min
tinyskateboard wrote:I would say you should probably do your own homework. Asking for help and asking someone for the answer are two totally different beasts.
I would normally do my own homework myself but I study music BUSINESS, and this is just something we have to do because.... i have no idea why! I don't play any instruments or read music in any way so it's a bit hard to comprehend it over night. I tried too but it was getting me nowhere hence I asked for help with this one even if 'help' is the actual answer

tinyskateboard · 2011-05-19 17:13

BBT: Can you rephrase that? I don't quite understand. ----- I'd really like to be able to figure this out...hmmm.

BodomBeachTerror · 2011-05-19 17:47

Find out all the notes in the chords, arrange them in order, and then play them and you'll get the key. Say we have a G, C, and a D (chords) the G has a G, B, and a D the C has a C, E, and a G the D has a D, F# and an A so if we play the notes in order: A B C D E F# G We end up with a G scale (or Eminor, if you want to swing that way), starting on an A. as a generalization, the first chord often holds the key of the song Although its not the way a "music theorist" would do it, it works usually.. unless you play out of key chords

gshredder2112 · 2011-05-19 17:56

Use the puzzle system guys. w w h w w w h <majscale formula 1--2--3--4--5--6--7 C d e f g a b the 1 is maj 2-min 3-min 4-maj 5-maj 6- min 7(dim)speakng in triads lets start with the intro you have cmaj-dmin-gmaj dmin is the second of cmaj so dmin is the 2 chord cmaj is the root of cmaj so cmaj is the 1 chord gmaj is the 5th of cmaj so gmaj is the 5chord soooo,basically the order you have your chords in your intro in in would be consideeed A 2-5-1 In cmaj.hopefully you understand a bit better,soory i dont have time to do it all,math finals,but any more questions feel free to ask.and maybe someone els can figure out 1 part. \M/(*-+) gs2112

gshredder2112 · 2011-05-19 17:58

Use the puzzle system
w  w  h  w  w   w  h  <majscale formula
1--2--3--4--5--6--7
C  d  e   f  g  a   b

the 1 is maj

2-min
3-min
4-maj
5-maj
6- min
7(dim)speakng in triads
lets start with the intro
you have cmaj-dmin-gmaj

dmin is the second of cmaj so dmin is the 2 chord
cmaj is the root of cmaj so cmaj is the 1 chord
gmaj is the 5th of cmaj so gmaj is the 5chord

soooo,basically the order you have your chords in your intro in in would be consideeed A 2-5-1 In cmaj.hopefully you understand a bit better,soory i dont have time to do it all,math finals,but any more questions feel free to ask.and maybe someone els can figure out 1 part.
\M/(*-+) gs2112

gshredder2112 · 2011-05-19 18:01

Use the puzzle system w w h w w w h <majscale formula 1--2--3--4--5--6--7 C d e f g a b the 1 is maj 2-min 3-min 4-maj 5-maj 6- min 7(dim)speakng in triads lets start with the intro you have cmaj-dmin-gmaj dmin is the second of cmaj so dmin is the 2 chord cmaj is the root of cmaj so cmaj is the 1 chord gmaj is the 5th of cmaj so gmaj is the 5chord soooo,basically the order you have your chords in your intro in in would be consideeed A 2-5-1 In cmaj.hopefully you understand a bit better,soory i dont have time to do it all,math finals,but any more questions feel free to ask.and maybe someone els can figure out 1 part. \M/(*-+) gs2112 Text for registered users onlyText for registered users only

gshredder2112 · 2011-05-19 18:03

Use the puzzle system w w h w w w h <majscale formula 1--2--3--4--5--6--7 C d e f g a b the 1 is maj 2-min 3-min 4-maj 5-maj 6- min 7(dim)speakng in triads lets start with the intro you have cmaj-dmin-gmaj dmin is the second of cmaj so dmin is the 2 chord cmaj is the root of cmaj so cmaj is the 1 chord gmaj is the 5th of cmaj so gmaj is the 5chord soooo,basically the order you have your chords in your intro in in would be consideeed A 2-5-1 In cmaj.hopefully you understand a bit better,soory i dont have time to do it all,math finals,but any more questions feel free to ask.and maybe someone els can figure out 1 part. \M/(*-+) gs2112

gshredder2112 · 2011-05-19 18:06

w w h w w w h <majscale formula 1--2--3--4--5--6--7 C--d--e--f--G--a--b--
-the 1 is maj
-----------2-min
------------3-min
------------4-maj
-------------5-maj
-------------6- min
-----------7(dim)speakng in triads
lets start with the intro you have cmaj-dmin-gmaj dmin is the second of cmaj so dmin is the 2 chord cmaj is the root of cmaj so cmaj is the 1 chord gmaj is the 5th of cmaj so gmaj is the 5chord soooo,basically the order you have your chords in your intro in in would be consideeed A 2-5-1 In cmaj.hopefully you understand a bit better,soory i dont have time to do it all,math finals,but any more questions feel free to ask.and maybe someone els can figure out 1 part. M/(*-+) gs2112

gshredder2112 · 2011-05-19 18:16

ok,sorry about the spam,idk what the hell happened.Anywho.i posted my response to this on my profile,Check.it out,it should.benefit everyone.

tinyskateboard · 2011-05-20 00:14

help me out here, applying the Puzzle axiom gets us to what key? what key is the song in??? TIA

JustJeff · 2011-05-20 06:10

So wait, you are doing music business, but have no interest in music? No wonder the music industry is crap :-P No offense, if you want to do business in something, you should at least understand it. To answer your question, the intro is in D dorian, your verse is in D dorian, and your chorus is C Mixolydian. And I'm assuming you transcribed it to chords yourself. Your "A# major" is really a "Bb Major". You modulate into the chorus from the verse. that's what that Gmin does. I never heard anyone say that it's the "puzzle" axiom. It is true you use wwhwwwh, but that's to find the Ionian of the scale. When you find the mode you've gotta push it around. I have a tendency nowadays to look at the chords to figure out the key. It's not the best way to do it, but it works.

gshredder2112 · 2011-05-20 09:40

^^^Jeff,a key cant be a modal name,its either maj or minor. @ tiny,go to my profile and look.if i use the puzzle for the intro i get 3 chords from cmaj,a 2-5-1.THe ionian chord scale in triads goes
w   w   h   w    w   w   h
maj-min-min-maj-maj-min-dim
 C   D            G        
^^those are the chords were given.so fill in the blanks and youll have a maj scale.1-2-5 or a 2-1-5 whatever way its in cmaj.like jeff explained,its alot of other things,but i would call it cmaj personnaly.I too tired to figure out the rest,but ill be here to answer more wuestions.

gx1327 · 2011-05-23 12:50

JustJeff wrote:To answer your question, the intro is in D dorian, your verse is in D dorian, and your chorus is C Mixolydian.
is this because the first note played is a D? (differentiating "D Dorian" from, say, "C Major") i agree that you should understand music if you are getting into music business, but what practical application does determining what key/mode a song is in based on its chords have? i really don't think this will ever come up in the real world...

JustJeff · 2011-05-23 17:39

@gshredder & @gx1327 I basically say that a song is in a key based on the starting chord and the resolving chord. So yes, it may be C major, but along with that, it's focusing on the Dorian mode. You can sort of inherently assume the Major/Minor key from what's given. I'm just trying to be a bit more specific. And yes, based on the starting/resolution note, I'm saying that it's D dorian... (It's still C major... just a mode of C major). As it may not come up in the real world. If I'm working with you and you know ** about music, I'm less likely to believe what you have to tell me.

gshredder2112 · 2011-05-23 18:09

Well,dorian would be a minor mode/key.It would be acceptable to say that his progression was derived from The D dorian mode,thats fine.But his question was to find the key of the song,D dorian is not a key,its a scale in the minor family.You could say it was in the key of D min,but that wouldnt be incorrect.The only answer.i can.come up.with is that its in.Cmaj. \M/(*-+) gs2112