the relative question of the day
*major or minor?
Minor
Why can't I have both?!
i guess so but waht do you tend to use more?
Suspended!!!!
Scales or chords?
uhh keys.
I use Minor more. But if i'm using an Em scale I like to mix it up and through in a G sharp or a C sharp.
minor
Lately it's Major. Been playing around with Major7 progressions.
Arent all keys major?
Good question. I really did not get the "keys" part?
Minor keys aren't major. Minor keys are minor.
I more often than not use Minor-esque keys.
However, I more often than not, use major chords :)
so you cant say this song is in the key of B minor?
I was thinking of key signatures. The Major key signature is the same as it's relative minor. C & Am = no sharps or flats.
iwas just talking about keys in ggeneral.and yes the relative minor of a major scale is the 6th,in cmaj it would be amin.your right mosh
Good question.....i would have to say minor high e thru d than major to low e
good description notim
When you say a song is in the key of B minor its actaully in D. Just starting on the 6th. But then could you start on the 2nd of a key for example the key of D and say your playing in the key of E minor? Or is saying your playing in the key of E minor mean automatically that your in the key of G?
but its still b minor.
Yes but all your chords are the exact same as if you were in D. But i just asked a friend and he said you can call a key the key of E dorian if your starting on the 2nd of the koey of D.
i dont know about using modal names as a key,ijust thought they were major or minor
ionian-maj
dorian-min
phyrgian-min
lydian-maj
mixolydian-maj
aeolian-min
locrian- diminished
That's why I say scales or chords. The method you guys are talking about only works if you are using diatonic scales/modes. I have played plenty of songs where the progression goes outside the diatonics.
nullnaught wrote:But i just asked a friend and he said you can call a key the key of E dorianif your starting on the 2nd of the koey of D.I don't think there is a KEY of E Dorian. That would be for scales/modes. The key is the signature of the song. To say a song is in the key of E Dorian is saying Dorian is the only mode I can use for this song??
i a song was in e dorian it would be
emin .
But are you playing it over a song in the key of E or D? The mode does not determine the key.
ahh good point mosh.so basically a key is either maj or min not a modal name dorian etc so if it was i cmaj you could use any of the seven modes in cmaj to solo ove rthe progreesion in cmaj.
you can play a minor key lead over a major scale , I will leave my self open
what about a diminished key?
damnit null,that i dont now the answer to .
dim7, a minor harmonic on the 12 fret harmonic e ,a g 1/4 bend into a half bend on the g
sorry i think i exploded
i dont get it.notim.your fishy.
Sorry about that allways have been whats fishy
ahhhh a 12th fret harmonic bend??? Magic powers!!
^^Bend behind the nut??
This is what I don't understand
Notim wrote:you can play a minor key lead over a major scaleI can understand a minor scale over a major chord or key!!
I can send you a recording of one of my harmonic bend
Natural or pinch?
I dont understand y u dont understand
i use whammy to bend 12th fret harmonic! and what about nullnaughts dim key question
natural and or pinch
damn what about artificial?
that happens by it self, thats what makes it hard to explain
dammit yall confusing me know....
*now
A bend behind the nut is what jimmy page does in the beggining of the solo heartbreaker.
i'm trying to think of away to explain, its one of those things that ya kinda just know after time
check your private message
a bend ehind the nut is when you hit an open note,harmonic and place your fingers near the string tree,and push down adding tension to the string causese a bending fx.
Minor