All Guitar Chords · Forum archive

Megadeth vs Metallica

ThePusher · 2008-07-09 21:49

It appears I've been gone to long in the midnight sea, but my vote is obviously for Megadeth because Metallica are far too popular and Kirk Hammet pisses me off, plus Megadeth started the Gigantour which anihilates man I went and I felt like cumming when it started dude

jarhead666 · 2008-07-12 17:57

Megadeath is way better of course!!

league · 2008-07-15 18:57

Megadeth definetely. Metallica having a video game just makes them less of as Metal band. Megadeths lyrics destroy Metallicas and the complexity yet simplistic form of Mustaines guitar work is few and far between. Anthrax is a good band too.

bivinshenry · 2008-08-16 19:55

metallica

baudelaire · 2008-08-16 23:24

mustaine isn't a quarter of the guitarist or songwriter that james + kirk are. his songs feel like a bunch of random takes slopped together. and slipknot is easily the biggest combination of not creative, and popular i have ever seen. they aren't even dedicated to their dumb masks. they're simply awful.

BodomBeachTerror · 2008-08-16 23:36

u can respect other ppls tastes in music and other musicians. dave may not be as good of a song writer as james, but in musical talent he is far ahead of kirk and james. as for slipknot they are extremely musically underrated

baudelaire · 2008-08-16 23:46

you must be kidding me, mustaine doesn't do a single thing better then kirk or james. james is a better soloist then mustaine, and he's the rhythm guitarist. slipknot... the only thing that could pass as mediocre are the lyrics, sometimes. musically, they're just another damned power chord band. nothing special. completely undeserving of fame, although, they would deserve a decent living playing clubs in some big city. they certainly have no right to be a international act.

BodomBeachTerror · 2008-08-16 23:49

listen to Poison was the Cure.. james could never write something that brilliant lol... then u have never listened to slipknot

baudelaire · 2008-08-17 00:03

i used to listen to them... when i was 11. as for poison was the cure, aside from the fact the intro was choppily connected to the main part of the song, the cool riffing there doesn't qualify as 'brilliant'. it's just lydian scales, with a 7sus4 arpeggio tossed in there. and then repeated over and over. yeah, it's a really cool song. but, yeah, kirk has done some stuff that was far more technical and complex. not that that makes it any better; it doesn't. but musicianshipwise, metallica beats out megadeth any day of the week.

ThePusher · 2008-08-17 17:17

Wow, maybe it's just me but I vote we the Megadeth fans boycott baudelaire, I fully agree with BBT Megadeths musicianship just crushes Metallica's I've seen Dave live and he rocks ass, watch that man play Hangar 18 live then tell me James Hetfield is a better soloist, all this bieng said there are hundreds of reasons to love or hate either band, I took Megadeth because in my oppinion they are leagues ahead of Metallica. Now on to the Slipknot issue, I hate NuMetal with a passion however I respect their musical ability, Joey Jordison truly can drum and if you took the time to watch Mick or Jim solo whihc they rarely do in Slipknot you would realize they're more than competent at it, so baudelaire it is my theory that you're young and naive to the ways of musical expression

EMB5490 · 2008-08-17 17:25

agree with pusher on the rfirst part, better mucisian ship but too heavy

CTown · 2008-08-17 21:25

All I really know from Megadeath is "Symphony of Destruction" so went w/ Metallica b/c of personal preference. But what exactly is so bad with the "Black Album"? Cause it brought them to the international foreground and everyone want to think of themselves as fans before they made it big? Ride the Lightning, Master of Puppets, and Kill Em All were all decent, but my favorite is Black. Maybe it's b/c I like it when they slow it down... like in "Nothing Else Matters" But I digress.

baudelaire · 2008-08-17 23:15

pusher, we'll just never agree. just leave it at, i think mustaine is a poor songwriter compared to james and kirk, and i think slipknot sucks in every single area. i think drumming is next to irrelevant to a bands skill. i've seen their solos. they feel uninspired and generic. as for not understanding musical expression, fuck off. i don't like bands that play power chords exclusively and don't do anything original, sue me - i 'd rather listen to coltraines India or Impressions. there's no point in arguing subjective points. it wastes both our time.

ThePusher · 2008-08-18 06:49

Well obvs if you're looking for expression you go to Jazz thats why I play Pastorius on bass XD however you are correct we're never gonna see eye to eye, and fyi in your ear about drumming being irelevant to a bands skill, thats just your ignorance and inability to play the instrument resulting in frustration and therefore you're going to call it down, look at great badns like Rush and Dream Theater, certainly Alex Lifeson and John Petrucci are amazing guitarist and John Myung and Geddy Lee are 2 stellar bassists, but the bands would not be the same without Neil Peart and Mike Portnoy, atleast get your fact straight before getting into it with someone who is enlightened to the ways of music and life

ironman91313 · 2008-08-27 22:08

baudelaire your just wrong. Mustaine is better then everybody in Metallica. he prolly can even play drums better than Lars

madman3123 · 2008-08-28 04:06

well slipknot fucking rocks they are underrated and if you listen to pyschosocial that is skilled and has an awsome solo =D

baudelaire · 2008-08-28 07:13

pusher, don't be a fucking moron. drumming is not only the simplest possible instrument, it would be arguable to say its NOT a instrument. it does not have melody or harmony, just rhythm. ever heard of a solo drummer? not only that, but now of days, drummers are USELESS, except for the fact that people like to see a drummer onstage. a world class drum machine is 500 dollars; you couldn't tell the difference between the two acoustically; the machine never fucks up; and you don't need a drummer to write good drum beats. anyone can, (and does) do it. the machine is better, easier to use, cheaper, more reliable, and sounds just as good. drummers are obsolete. they are decoration. and, as a matter of fact, i can play drums better then the old drummer for my band, and i'm a guitarist. see, every REAL instrument requires as much or more rhythm skill then drumming. and if you can smack things good, you can drum. *i* put the drum tracks on the record, the drummer couldn't do it. so we canned him and got a machine, that has done very well for us. and some 19 year old punk with poor english, no musical knowledge and a thumb up his ass isn't enlightened about ANYTHING, much less music and life. ironman, how do you want to judge guitarists? when it comes down to it, kirk plays faster. and, he can play better slower. and, his solos are actually complex (for metal at least) instead of just being scalar masturbation. what specifically does mustaine have on hammet other then your fandom?

EMB5490 · 2008-08-28 08:20

are u kidding me baudelaire...drums are fking hard, i cant play those for shit, and i did try for a while. also drums keep tempo, and sure u can use a machine, but ur not gona get energy, volume and any of tht stuff outta a machine

ironman91313 · 2008-08-28 10:19

@baud kirk doesnt play faster, and cant write solos. I mean cmon, he stole Dave's stuff a long time ago. If he was so good why would he need to do that? oh and i guess your right on the drumming, doesnt look too hard... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rmIpuWgt65k

jcb3000 · 2008-08-28 10:47

wtf! a drum is infact the worlds oldest instrument. and for the drum machine part, they are alot less versatile than a normal drummer. plus you can always say that about the guitar and just slap in on a track and play it back stage. maybe even vocals too and before you know it theres no band.

EMB5490 · 2008-08-28 11:19

and also i find the bass pedal fking impossible to time. its hard. dont talk about somthing unlesss u no its a fact. like the yankees kill the red sox. phip will get on tht 1 im sure.

Calvin · 2008-08-28 14:19

@baudelaire: "drumming is not only the simplest possible instrument, it would be arguable to say its NOT a instrument. it does not have melody or harmony, just rhythm. " Depends on how you look at it really. Different kinds of drums and cymbals have different pitches, so drumming obviously does have some melodic characteristics. "ever heard of a solo drummer? " So I guess that Neil Peart (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NuOTkrEVeb4) and Tomas Haake (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1TImErpkavs) are basically just solo guitarists posing as drummers.=P "not only that, but now of days, drummers are USELESS, except for the fact that people like to see a drummer onstage." Yeah,sure, the fact that drum machines can't interact with other instrumentalists during the live set, can't adopt to unpredictable situations, sound unnatural and sure can't improvise, doesn't have anything to do with it of course. Ever seen a jazz band jamming with a drum machine? "world class drum machine is 500 dollars; you couldn't tell the difference between the two acoustically; the machine never fucks up; ..yada, yada.. the machine is better, easier to use, cheaper, more reliable, and sounds just as good. drummers are obsolete. they are decoration." top notch professional music and mixing software, that will allow you to compose believable guitar solos by simply using the guitar samples, costs much less. Does that make guitarists even more useless than drummers? "and you don't need a drummer to write good drum beats. anyone can, (and does) do it...yada, yada..see, every REAL instrument requires as much or more rhythm skill then drumming. and if you can smack things good, you can drum." Sure, I'd certainly like to see a guitarist write a tastefully done polyrhythmical drum part using ,let's say, 7/8 , 6/8 ,5/16 and 29/32 time signatures. Hell, most guitarists can't even play polyrhythmically, let alone write that kind of stuff for some other instrument. "and, as a matter of fact, i can play drums better then the old drummer for my band, and i'm a guitarist. " So you haven't had a chance to play with a good drummer.And? With your ego and attitude we can clearly see why.:P

baudelaire · 2008-08-28 15:13

"Depends on how you look at it really. Different kinds of drums and cymbals have different pitches, so drumming obviously does have some melodic characteristics.Good drummers are aware of that and incorporate them in their playing." everything that vibrates has a pitch, but that doesn't mean it's based on the dodecasection of the octave. it's not 'melodic' it's merely different sounding. "So I guess that Neil Peart and Tomas Haake are basically just solo guitarists posing as drummers.=P " neil uses a xylophone as well, a real instrument, and tomas haake, should in my opinion not be able to earn a living drumming solo. i find it dreadfully boring... like a plate with no food. at least neil has the xylophone. "Yeah,sure, the fact that drum machines can't interact with other instrumentalists during the live set, can't adopt to unpredictable situations, sound unnatural and sure can't improvise, doesn't have anything to do with it of course. Ever seen a jazz band jamming with a drum machine?" they can interact, in that the musicians can program it to insert certain alternate bars at their wish with a footswitch. and a good one doesn't sound unnatural - i bet you couldn't tell which was a DR880 and which was a real drummer on a record, if they recorded the real one very well. more records then you might imagine were recorded with drum machines - i believe prince used a alesis sr-18 on his first album, it might have been another. drummers don't need to improvise, doing so is as upsettingly stupid as drummers soloing. and a jazz band could use a drum machine if they wished. no, it's not as flexible as a excellent drummer, but it makes up for that in every other area. "top notch professional music and mixing software, that will allow you to compose believable guitar parts by simply using the guitar samples, costs much less. Does that make guitarists even more useless than drummers?" no, because in a guitar oriented musical ensemble, they are the centerpiece, and you came to see them. say, a solo singer, could use a guitar backing track, because it's not central. furthermore, the level of knowledge and creativity required to write excellent guitar parts is not even comparable to the smattering of creativity and rhythmic sense it takes to write a good beat. "Sure, I'd certainly like to see a guitarist write a tastefully done polyrhythmical drum part using ,let's say, 7/8 , 6/8 ,5/16 and 29/32 time signatures. Hell, most guitarists can't even play polyrhythmically, yet alone compose that way on some other instrument." when i write music, i start with a melody i envision, and then the harmony and rhythm simply require creative use of my training. the time signature serves the melody; with the exception of 29/32, i have written tasteful drum parts for all of those signatures. it's not difficult. i composed a polyrhythmic piece for clarinet, classical guitar and timpanies before for extra credit in class. polyrhythm is by far the EASIEST part of higher level theory to grasp... "So you haven't had a chance to play with a good drummer.And? With your ego and attitude we can clearly see why.:P" say what you want about my attitude, i am not very egotistical...

Nightmare · 2008-08-28 15:17

both suck!!!

EMB5490 · 2008-08-28 16:07

"they can interact, in that the musicians can program it to insert certain alternate bars at their wish with a footswitch. and a good one doesn't sound unnatural - i bet you couldn't tell which was a DR880 and which was a real drummer on a record, if they recorded the real one very well. more records then you might imagine were recorded with drum machines - i believe prince used a alesis sr-18 on his first album, it might have been another. drummers don't need to improvise, doing so is as upsettingly stupid as drummers soloing. and a jazz band could use a drum machine if they wished. no, it's not as flexible as a excellent drummer, but it makes up for that in every other area." can they write music? didnt think so? the difference between a very reaalistic drum machine and a drummer, the drummer has life, dynamics not set to a computers exactness, the diff? one make mistakes and the other doesnt. i can copy rhoads songs play them to a precise measurment, but i will never be rhoads. its the same thing.

baudelaire · 2008-08-28 17:10

you don't need a drummer to write drum parts. good drum machines are most certainly dynamic, for example i can tap "tsh tsh tsh tsh TSSHHH" on my drum machine and it sounds just like someone tapped softly 4 times on a hat and then thwacked it hard. it sounds perfect. it's exact. it doesn't constantly mooch your drugs, food and alcohol, show up late, get lazy, bitch and moan... etc. being rhoads is a hell of a lot different then having his drummer in a box.

Empirism · 2008-08-28 17:26

Maybe you dont need a drummer for drum parts with utilities we have today. Ive made songs with sequencer a long time and with virtual instruments, but everytime I play with my band and our drummer, I remember why does not any utility beat any drummer on inspiration. And jamming.

league · 2008-08-28 17:47

Baudelaire seems like an expert so I'm not going to argue with him about music theory. You've got to agree Dave Mustaines lyrics are better. Megadeth just rocks harder! Baudelaire, I am not being sarcastic but with your musical knowledge I would like to hear you play a Thrash or Metal song.

EMB5490 · 2008-08-28 18:44

you can think of a drum part but ther will always be somthing missing with a machine, and can a machine write lyrics nd songs? didnt think so. and btw no in terms its not, i can play rhoads parts but i will NEVER sound like him or replace him to his extant same thing for a drum machine.

baudelaire · 2008-08-28 19:36

EMB, seriously, are you stupid? drumming is a very simple task. even with complicated jazz rhythms... and i've found the best drumming to be minimalist with great mixing anyways. a proper mix is the difference between dope and nope. who the hell said anything about a drum machine writing lyrics and and songs? being a drummer doesn't mean you can do either. and yes, ozzies drummer could be recorded, and then a machine could record it, and you couldn't tell the difference. unless he did a shitty job drumming, then you'd know it had to be a human. megadeth vs metallica is opinion. the only real concrete way to judge is with record sales. metallica entertains more people. more people like them. in the only real non subjective way they can be judged, metallica wins. league, i DO play metal for the fun of it at times. metal is simple. 99% of ALL music is simple. even most classical music is simple. music is a startlingly simple thing once you grasp the knowledge behind it; you can not understand how important creative genius is until you have a great understanding of theory. "if you are really pushing life to the limits, you will learn how limited life is". empirism, obviously drummers have a real edge when it comes to jamming and drum writing. just not enough to justify their role. john henry has lost.

EMB5490 · 2008-08-28 19:48

drum machines cant! u dont think drummers write songs? and anyway id love to see the laughs some 1 gets when they go onstage and say ther using a drum machine. drumming IS NOT a simple task any drummer would be offended, what makes it so simple eh?

league · 2008-08-28 20:31

@EMB HipHop DJs use drum machines on stage and their fans love em.LOL @Baudelaire.Excuse my tone, I am being serious. You agree with most that Metallica is better because of record sales. Would you say that it is a coincidence that more people choose Metallica over Megadeth and Metallica is musically superior, or do you assume they all know as much as you do and thats why they love Metallica? You clearly know more theory than us yet you still argue with us and resort to electronic sampling of drums over a real drummer. Also, anyone that knows about Metal, knows that Metallica and Megadeth changed their sound to please the majority of consumers. Metallica, however, surpassed Megadeth in popularity and record sales. Post "And Justice For All" Metallica songs are heard on the radio and reached people like Skold(no offense) who dislikes Metal yet chooses Metallica over Megadeth. Could you just clear that up for me Baudelaire?

EMB5490 · 2008-08-28 21:54

lol hip hop djs, lol. and the only reason tht i like metallica more is ther a little less heavy, musically megadeth is better.

baudelaire · 2008-08-28 22:08

EMB, people MIGHT laugh, and they'd be wrong - and if you do your job, by the end of the show, they'll have had a great time, and it won't matter at all that you used a drum machine. in fact, most people probably wouldn't care - it would sound just as good in any event. in my opinion, i can get a better, more even drum sound using a machine, because every sample was perfected already, and a single line out is easier to manage then 6 mics and a mixer and a shitload of equipment to go along with it. it's very easy to dial in the right drum tone to blend with the other elements - and once it starts thumping, people forget there is no drummer. and a drummer isn't any better at composing music then the average joe off the street. they make drum beats better then the average joe off the street, thats all. drumming IS a simple task that can, like all simple tasks, be made more complicated then it needs to be. and, in any event, my machine can handle that complicated stuff just as well. i say this: i say there is no real way to say which band is better based on opinion and argument of talent. the only solid thing we have is numbers; and metallica has sold more records. now, depending on how you look at it, that could mean something, or it could mean nothing. it could mean that as entertainers they are superior because they entertain more people, or it could mean that they 'sold out' and didn't make music for its own sake. it could be taken either way. i'm not sure what you are asking here; i enjoy metallica more then megadeth because i am more pleased by their music, the cause of that i discern to be superior songwriting ability, superior musicanmanship, including singing and lyrical content. but that is mere opinion. if i want to present a argument based on fact, there is no fact but record sales. i am not saying that that is why i like them, i'm saying thats the only factual way to judge them on a extrapersonal level. as for the changing of their sound, i see that as a good thing. but that is just opinion, as is my opinion that it is a good thing, because on metallicas part at least their talent and dedication remained consistent, and they avoided musical stagnation, which i believe would be a fate worse then softening to appeal to more people. and i don't personally see anything wrong with that - whether or not i would do it, i see it as justifiable. and i don't resort to a drum machine; i choose it because i prefer the advantages it carries. it works far better for me then a real drummer. i don't have to split money with it, help it move things, help mic it, have to work around it's schedule, argue with it, cope with it's failures, share pharmaceuticals with it, teach it the new part, wait for him to learn it, it's available at any time, sounds better, more flexible, bigger memory, etc. etc...

EMB5490 · 2008-08-29 07:40

tell u what u go use a machine and tell me the feedback u get...

Nutter166 · 2008-08-29 09:00

I like early metallica stuff the more recent (st.anger,death magnetic) are extremely disappointing =[ in that way MegaDeath are better .-. so for me I like both ahaha =] and the drumming thing..I stopped drumming and picked up gutiar because drumming was to fucking hard .-. also I was moving and wouldn't have a drumkit to use anymore -_-

ironman91313 · 2008-08-29 09:32

@baud but megadeth is just better

baudelaire · 2008-08-29 11:35

EMB, i have done a LOT of shows, and no one has EVER complained about the drum machine.

EMB5490 · 2008-08-29 11:40

thts b/c they complain about everything else...lol soz had to say it, tht was like a setup for an allyoop over dr.j. lol im jk of course, doesnt it feel wierd to play with a machine?! lol owned again hehe, my 14 year oldness is taking over...on all seriousness, at least if it screw up u can beat the living dalights outta it and if it survies it cant quit the band. lol

ironman91313 · 2008-08-29 12:23

so what if the thing cant make a mistake or complain or whatever, I just think its stupid to have a machine playing an instrument. why not just make the whole band machines, it will never complain or make mistakes! I would not want to live in that world

Notim · 2008-08-29 13:55

Well I think that Dave got F***ed over by Metallica,I was around when it started and I personally dont listen to or play any of there music, MegaDeath is better in my opion,not by what I said above but because I think there guitar work is better,But the drumming conversation could go on for eon's.....sounds like were heading to the rap conversation again...........Lmao

keniemn · 2008-08-29 15:35

metallica started goin down hill with the black album megadeth keeps comin out with good shit vote for megadeth

blackholesun · 2008-08-29 16:44

keniemn wrote:megadeth keeps comin out with good shit
One word - "Risk".

BodomBeachTerror · 2008-08-29 17:07

blackholesun wrote:keniemn says: megadeth keeps comin out with good shit One word - "Risk".
true.. but at least they admit that it sucks lol

league · 2008-08-31 16:05

LOL Risk was not good but The System has Failed and United Abominations gave new hope to speed Metal. Its just hard to find good lyrics and clean or semi-clean vocals.